The "Is This a Fair Trade?" Thread

[lucifer morningstar]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... _nwbpdQfvg

I'm trying to get all of the Cs pets to give away one day with a item on each pet. I need to know if I should do this or not

I believe unfair to you. 5 C$ is about a '13-'14 rare, and a '16 rare wouldn't cover the gap between that and your '10 rare. I'd get a second opinion to be sure though.

[Sarin]

Oh gosh could I get some help with this one please? If it's not fair, what could be added to make it fair?

[Kabuski]

Is this fair? If not what could they add?

Wanting one more opinion ^>^

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... RfGQhdDOnA
this to!

[pigeon -]

How does this trade look for rarity and demand wise? I know quantity is a good booster c:

Quantity is good, but when you break it down, it's less than a Sorbet worth, and a CEG can be swapped with a Non now and then, with it's good demand c: List wise, it's unfair to you. Same demand wise.

Thank you! Would you know what roughly would be added? If I value it a bit higher
because of quantity, would another sorbet-ish pet and another high demand one be okay? c:

[rain,]

Yeah thats the nonswirl sorry XD!

[dakotapaws]

how does this bid look?

Very unfair to you ^^' Your store pet is worth about a 2010' ish rare (pls don't hurt me if I get this trade wrong ;w;) and possibly could get more with demand (even if it isn't a warrior;) Even if the quanity looks tempting, I don't believe it adds up to the worth of the store pet ^^'

thank you. second opinion?

also this one?

[tigresplayz]

help? could I get more?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... SXLbYeH4xw

I feel like a month ago we got the new thread XD

[LLHBBB]

Oh gosh could I get some help with this one please? If it's not fair, what could be added to make it fair?

unfair to you. The gap between the Bee and the Phoenix is 2 sorbets and the joker can fetch way more than that.

[☽isa☾]

Isn't that the non-swirl?

[Sarin]

Oh gosh could I get some help with this one please? If it's not fair, what could be added to make it fair?

unfair to you. The gap between the Bee and the Phoenix is 2 sorbets and the joker can fetch way more than that.

Thanks, that's what I figured. I'd really like to make this trade work, so could you give me some advice on how much they'd need to add to make it fair?