The "Is This a Fair Trade?" Thread

[lovage]

Rare Trade, Thank you in advance. <3

Unfair to you
The Llama on their side goes for a late 2009 rare.
The BW on your side is worth two 2009 rares, and the items also on your side are worth a 2009 uncommon- sometimes they can be swapped with a rare of the year each. Your trade partner needs to add.

Thank you, may I get a second opinion please?

I agree... very unfair to your side.

[pigeon -]

How does this trade look for rarity and demand wise? I know quantity is a good booster c:

Quantity is good, but when you break it down, it's less than a Sorbet worth, and a CEG can be swapped with a Non now and then, with it's good demand c: List wise, it's unfair to you. Same demand wise.

Thank you! Would you know what roughly would be added? If I value it a bit higher
because of quantity, would another sorbet-ish pet and another high demand one be okay? c:

[ilya]

Is this fair? also i'd like to know if the list pet they re offering has good demand or not.
Thanks in advance for any help♡

[Sarin]

Is this trade fair? I don't care about any of the pets they offered except the Moonswirl, so is it worth all the pets on my side?

[Kreiss]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... QfVvjKhsQg
faiir?

[dakotapaws]

how does this bid look?

[Sinbreaker]

Is this trade fair? I don't care about any of the pets they offered except the Moonswirl, so is it worth all the pets on my side?

woah Jokers go for way more

Your probably confusing it for the Non-Swirl.
The Moonswirl is worth 4 Nons. A Joker, with demand only goes for a Non to UR Aussie.
I counted about 4 Nons and almost 2 Sorbets worth.
I would remove the UR Holly and Red Toxic, and add in something around a Sorbet for it to be fair c:

[drakoh]

anyone think this is fair or not ?

[Silverstar]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=58564397&userid=824378&signature=FxTmfyxKgF0hQfVvjKhsQg
faiir?

A '13 store pet is worth about a mid '09 rare, they're overpaying.

[lucifer morningstar]

Can I get an opinion on this trade?

Also, would a UR butterfly wolf be fair for a Dogtag, demand wise? I know the UR BW is higher on the list, I'm just wondering which is going to be easier to trade off demand wise..

Any help for either of these would be very much appreciated. c:
-lucifer morningstar