closed! go to new thread!

[Takk]

Would this trade be fair to both sides? If not, what should be added or taken away?
Thank you.

Considering the demand of the store pet, they are underpaying a lot.

Okay, thanks!
Does anyone have an idea on what they should add?

Their side is worth a mid '09 rare, so by rarity the gap is around an '10 uncommon
Demand value is opinion based, so that's up to you. Ponies have lower demand compared to dogs and some people say '11 store pets go for 2 '09 rares (excluding the list ones of course). So anything from another '09 rare to the '10 uncommon could be added

[darn]

Is this fair?
Edit;
Is this fair as well? Thanks~

[soul reaver]

is this trade fair to the both of us? if not, what would need to be changed? ;v;
thanks in advance to anyone who can lend a hand c:

EDIT: and this?

[The Üpside Down]

Was this fair?
Edit, also this?

[discoverthedark]

Is this fair or close to fair for my Sorbet? I really like the pets and the C$.
This Bid
Thank you!

[Kream]

How would a UR B-Wolf look for a set of liontails?

[gallifrey falls.]

Is this fair or close to fair for my Sorbet? I really like the pets and the C$.
This Bid
Thank you!

According to this thread, Sorbets are worth 765 C$. They're offering 300 straight C$, so that leaves 465 they need to have in pet value. Their side ends up roughly at 570 C$, give or take.
In a sense they're overpaying, but trading from the main list all the way down to the Advent list a big leap. So it depends on whether you think you'll get a better trade down, keeping in mind not a lot of people are willing to trade their list pets for straight C$, or 09 rares, making it hard to climb or get on the list once you're low or off it.
Basically, the trade is fair but it's up to you whether you want to take it ^-^

[Coraychi]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... jQvIgRM63w

Is this fair? I'm really bad with cross-year trades and stuff >n>

[Coraychi]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... jQvIgRM63w

Is this fair? I'm really bad with cross-year trades and stuff >n>

[Niragi]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=56386350&userid=44074&signature=HvhzsRo2NaMpjQvIgRM63w

Is this fair? I'm really bad with cross-year trades and stuff >n>

Even though the rarities might seem to make it a 'fair trade', due to the demand you can most likely get three to four 09 rares for that zodiac dog, maybe even more if the person is looking for that certain sign, so I would say it's unfair but that depends on how you value the nick pet dog
You better get a second opinion though!