closed! go to new thread!

[Asvoria]

Got two trades for my chesire, I'm kinda unsure which one is more fair
I appreciate any help <3

1. http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 9CBKiMvT9w
2. http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... vn9j7zJTAw

Also I said that I only trade the Chesire to twoever presents me with this Tess dragon, If I was trading the Chesire for the 2011 VR Tess dragon, how much would it be to add to their side to make it fair?

Thanks for any help <3

[zenzi]

I know rarity wise, its unfair to the balloon dog, how does it look demand wise regarding the balloon dog + the store basilisk and marionette, would this be worth taking? is the balloon dog easier to trade up/down?

it looks alright ot me tbh.
the marionette can get the occasional low main and the set can go for mid-ish septs
personally i've found that the balloon was really easy to trade for overpay and to trade down in the past =]

[soul reaver]

i know they're overpaying with c$, but since trading c$ for list pets is such a daunting task, would i be better off accepting and trading off the c$ for other lists or should i just cancel and wait for a better "on-list" offer?

I think you should accept it before they realize it's an extreme overpay

could i get a second opinion, anyone?

[FreddyCenobite]

Is this fair?

'09 wise I think it is missing another rare, but is a '10 enough? (the items are hoards/on WL for decorative purposes so kind of ignore those)

[Sarcastic Hawke]

Would this trade be considered fair? The rat is from 2009 I believe so I'm not sure the store pet on my end will cover the rarity/age.

[Takk]

i know they're overpaying with c$, but since trading c$ for list pets is such a daunting task, would i be better off accepting and trading off the c$ for other lists or should i just cancel and wait for a better "on-list" offer?

I think you should accept it before they realize it's an extreme overpay

could i get a second opinion, anyone?

Issue 1, please do not encourage people to accept unfair trades. Scamming and ninja'ing are terrible acts, do not support them in any way, shape or form.
2ndly, it's overpay because the Blood PPS is worth 300-315C$ however I would be against accepting for demand reasons. The pets only add to 2 '09 rares and the rest would be purely C$. In my experience, people will offer uncommon bulk or low demand rares for C$ (horses, ponies, rats, sometimes dogs) and I can say with certainty you could not get back a list pet offering just C$
So, unless you have other list pets that would help you trade up the list, I probably wouldn't accept myself since you'd likely be losing a Sept list and gaining various off list pets instead

[zenzi]

i know they're overpaying with c$, but since trading c$ for list pets is such a daunting task, would i be better off accepting and trading off the c$ for other lists or should i just cancel and wait for a better "on-list" offer?

I think you should accept it before they realize it's an extreme overpay

could i get a second opinion, anyone?

the c$ is worth around a balloon dog
personally i've found it very difficult to trade away c$ for list pets, as many people do. i wouldn't do it just because its a risk.

Would this trade be considered fair? The rat is from 2009 I believe so I'm not sure the store pet on my end will cover the rarity/age.

quite unfair to them, the rat is a '09 re-release and your pet is only worth a '10 rare

[Caffeinated_Curl]

Is this fair?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=56268460&userid=676414&signature=-k2nhVkSkJyIA4beyavu0g
Thanks in advance! :3

[Jiloon]

Would this trade be considered fair? The rat is from 2009 I believe so I'm not sure the store pet on my end will cover the rarity/age.

Technically, it's very unfair to the rat, which is an '09 very rare. However, rats have almost no demand. Personally, I wouldn't take the rat, even though it's extreme overpay...

[Soming]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... ldq4P_zGIQ

Is this a fair trade?