closed! go to new thread!

[Kabuski]

Is this fair?

Thank you!

Its an over-trade, the store pet is only worth a 2010 rare

[God's Princess]

Is this fair? Thank you! ~God's Princess

[Butt3rflyJB]

Sorry for the longer post...
I've been offline for a couple of years now and am trying to get back into the swing of things. As a result, I have quite a few older pets that I've been trying to trade for newer ones. I would like to double-check some of my already-completed trades just to be sure I am gauging my year and rarity differences appropriately. Thank you!

Simpler Trades
Trade 1 - 2 2016 Commons for 1 2016 Uncommon
Trade 2 - 4 2016 Very Commons for 1 2016 Uncommon
Trade 3 - 4 2014 Commons for 2 2013 Commons
Trade 4 - 3 2016 Very Commons for 1 2014 Very Common

More Complex Trades
Trade 5 - 4 2016 Commons + 2 2016 Uncommons for 2015 Rare
Trade 6 - 1 2016 Common + 1 2016 Uncommon for 2014 Common
Trade 7 - 4 2014 Very Commons + 6 2014 Commons + 1 2014 Uncommon for 1 2013 Common + 2 2013 Uncommons
Trade 8 - 2 2016 Very Commons + 8 2016 Commons + 6 2016 Uncommons for 1 2013 OMG So Common + 1 2013 Very Common + 3 2013 Commons + 1 2012 Very Common + 2 2012 Commons

Looking for a second opinion. Thank you!

[Jiloon]

Is this fair?

Thank you!

They are overpaying many times over. A 2015 store pet is generally worth a '10 rare, though this particular one has some demand, so you could probably get a mid-late '09 rare for it c:

[LemonadeQueen]

This fair? Thanks so much!

[BB-8]

Is this fair?
Thanks in advance!

[Kiinotasha]

Is this trade overpay?

I am unsure of these as well.
1 2

Thank you for your help.

[XIII DEATH]

Is this trade fair?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... hiM6ijeo-A

Thank you!

[The Üpside Down]

Is this fair?

[Rebel~Child]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... dutZbbpgWg

They accepted o.o

Was it fair???