~Warrior Cats Fan Club V.5~

[twisti]

oh man I just realized Redtail was Tigerstar's uncle.


Redtail's sister was Leopardfoot, who was Tigerstar's mother.



I swear everyone in these books is related in some way.

I'm not really surprised. I personally believe that Half-Clan cats should be influenced because if cats weren't Half-Clan than even more cousins and siblings will mate and everything will be insane. I mean the cats don't usually have a lot of cats so there aren't many mate choices already.

[while it lasted.]

Was Ashfur Ivypool's and Dovewing's father? It makes a LOT of sense....Ivypool and Dovewing look nothing like Birchfall (who is a brown tabby) and don't look all that much like their mother (who is white). Neither of them have Whitewing's eyes (green) OR Birchfall's eyes either (amber). They both have blue eyes and their pelts both have gray! So who are their parents?

[SnowoFall]

Was Ashfur Ivypool's and Dovewing's father? It makes a LOT of sense....Ivypool and Dovewing look nothing like Birchfall (who is a brown tabby) and don't look all that much like their mother (who is white). Neither of them have Whitewing's eyes (green) OR Birchfall's eyes either (amber). They both have blue eyes and their pelts both have gray! So who are their parents?

Well, Whitewing is DEFINITELY their mother. And there have been theories that ash fur was Ivy's and Dove's father. But I do believe that one of the Erins said that was false and that Birchfall was the father

[twisti]

Was Ashfur Ivypool's and Dovewing's father? It makes a LOT of sense....Ivypool and Dovewing look nothing like Birchfall (who is a brown tabby) and don't look all that much like their mother (who is white). Neither of them have Whitewing's eyes (green) OR Birchfall's eyes either (amber). They both have blue eyes and their pelts both have gray! So who are their parents?

Well, Whitewing is DEFINITELY their mother. And there have been theories that ash fur was Ivy's and Dove's father. But I do believe that one of the Erins said that was false and that Birchfall was the father

Ashfur was not the father. I believe the Erins confirmed it and it really wouldn't have had a purpose anyways besides creating even more drama.

[redlitt]

Was Ashfur Ivypool's and Dovewing's father? It makes a LOT of sense....Ivypool and Dovewing look nothing like Birchfall (who is a brown tabby) and don't look all that much like their mother (who is white). Neither of them have Whitewing's eyes (green) OR Birchfall's eyes either (amber). They both have blue eyes and their pelts both have gray! So who are their parents?

Well, Whitewing is DEFINITELY their mother. And there have been theories that ash fur was Ivy's and Dove's father. But I do believe that one of the Erins said that was false and that Birchfall was the father

Ashfur was not the father. I believe the Erins confirmed it and it really wouldn't have had a purpose anyways besides creating even more drama.

Despite it being disproven, I still like thinking about it. For some reason I ship Ashfur x Whitewing (not as much as Ashfur x Scourge, of course).

[Tendo64]

Is it bad that I don't ship or understand AshfurXScourge? I mean, I'm not bashing anyone for it, but I don't get it. I know it's a "revenge" shipping, but even then, Ashfur and Scourge didn't even speak to one another. At all, actually. Of course, Ashfur(Ashpaw, actually. He was still an apprentice) obviously hated him, but they weren't arch enemies or anything. It just seems so random...

Another thing: I see art of Scourge always being depicted smiling creepily or something. Scourge is clearly insane and probably sadistic, but he wasn't like that. When he killed Tigerstar, he wasn't laughing maniacally or anything. He simply sat there with an uninterested expression. That shows he's more of a cold, unsettling cat.

[redlitt]

I don't ship Ashfur x Scourge due to it being a revenge ship. I saw some fanart... and it made me fall into shipping it.

[twisti]

Is it bad that I don't ship or understand AshfurXScourge? I mean, I'm not bashing anyone for it, but I don't get it. I know it's a "revenge" shipping, but even then, Ashfur and Scourge didn't even speak to one another. At all, actually. Of course, Ashfur(Ashpaw, actually. He was still an apprentice) obviously hated him, but they weren't arch enemies or anything. It just seems so random...

Another thing: I see art of Scourge always being depicted smiling creepily or something. Scourge is clearly insane and probably sadistic, but he wasn't like that. When he killed Tigerstar, he wasn't laughing maniacally or anything. He simply sat there with an uninterested expression. That shows he's more of a cold, unsettling cat.

I agree with everything you said! I just don't understand how the ship started at all, and I do like Scourge fan art (it has that creepy thing I love), but he wasn't sadistic or mad at all. He just wanted revenge at everyone. He killed Tigerstar for revenge when he was a kit, and just hated everyone unless they were in BloodClan.

[bronzebones]

According to a personality chart, I'm Yellowfang! ISTP!




I wish that Clans were accepting of half-clan kits. In my opinion, as long as the parents work out who gets the kits, it's fine. If they don't work it out, the mother should get the kits by default.

[Tendo64]

According to a personality chart, I'm Yellowfang! ISTP!




I wish that Clans were accepting of half-clan kits. In my opinion, as long as the parents work out who gets the kits, it's fine. If they don't work it out, the mother should get the kits by default.

Honestly, I don't get why Clans hate each other so much at all. I mean, sure, you should be loyal to your Clan and I can understand territory disputes, but I remember back in Bluestar's Prophecy that a RiverClan cat wanted territory just so ThunderClan didn't have it. That's pretty cold.

And, I know they're cats, but Warriors has cats that have more human-like emotions and feelings rather than cat instincts alone.