I am not a traditional rater but I do have some opinions! I am not aiming to offend and I believe everyone gets a chance to be creative, but I do share some similar views with traditional people! (Summary: I'm a mix)
Ratings:
╒══════════════════════════════════════╕
Mistwhisker
╘══════════════════════════════════════╛
» 7/10
» I like the name, but what gets me is 'Mist' and 'Whisk' collide together a bit, if you know what I mean. Also 'Whisker' usually refers to hunting or tracking skills. Maybe 'heart' might be better?
╒══════════════════════════════════════╕
Mintleaf
╘══════════════════════════════════════╛
» 4/10
» The actual name is okay, but the scenario doesn't suit her. Cream color, 'leaf' prefix, and deputy don't mix together quite well. 'Leaf' is often used for medicine cats and 'Mint' is more common in grey colored cats and occasionally white.
╒══════════════════════════════════════╕
Rosethorn
╘══════════════════════════════════════╛
» 9/10
» I like the name, it runs together well and it suits her. I like it
My cats:
╒══════════════════════════════════════╕
Embercloud
╘══════════════════════════════════════╛
» Embercloud is a gorgeous dark grey she-cat with small ginger patches and white markings of a tortoiseshell. Her coat long and thick, often getting tangled easily with it's exceptionally long fur. She has tall and rounded ears with a deep pink nose with thin black lining and beautiful pale green eyes.
» Although she might not be the best at hunting or fighting, Embercloud has a steady mind and a calm aura. Though she is near to motherly, she has a depth of patience that is used best with soothing others that are hostile or shocked. She is very optimistic and loves nearly everything. She tends to speak her mind, before even her mind knows what she is saying. However, she's rather easy to confuse and trick.
» 'Ember' for her dark grey, orange, and white pelt
» 'Cloud' for her motherly and optimistic personality
----------------------------------------------------------------
╒══════════════════════════════════════╕
Lightwhisker
╘══════════════════════════════════════╛
» Lightwhisker is a light coated silver tom with swirling light grey mackerel tabby markings slightly darker than his base coat. He has a muscular build despite being legit weight and he has small paws. He has tall and pointy ears and a light pink nose. He has milky green eyes which are always full of curiosity and wonder.
» While he may be soft spoken, don't take this for granted for Lightwhisker understands more than meets the eye. He tends to tease a lot, but always in good nature. While being stuck up in the medicine den may sound boring, he makes sure to fill his extra time around his family, getting to know them better. He's especially fond of his best friend and sister Embercloud. He's also a very good hunter and can sniff out most anything, whether it be cats, prey, or herbs.
» 'Light' for his light silver coat
» 'Whisker' for his tracking ability
----------------------------------------------------------------
╒══════════════════════════════════════╕
Hawkstep
╘══════════════════════════════════════╛
» Hawkstep is a well-built brown tom with black tabby stripes and a white muzzle, paws, and a very fluffy white chest and belly. His eyes are an ice blue that are occasionally blurred but are still able to see most of the time. He has big paws and a very loud voice that he continues to attempt to control. He's very muscular and has a short coat.
» Hawkstep is a very loyal warrior and quite skillful in both hunting and fighting. He is intelligent and is sometimes the voice of reason in a situation if it demands it. He's bad at flirting. He is confident in battle but is a bit close-minded, but he tries to understand everyone else’s opinions. He is kind to those around him and quite calm most of the time, but comes to be very defensive about family and honor. Sometimes he needs someone to help him apologize for things he does, as he's often too honory to do it, but he makes up for his mistakes one way or another. He's loud and obnoxious sometimes but when situation needs it, he can be as silent as a hawk on watch. He's highly observant and can often tell if someone is lying to him or hiding something.
» 'Hawk' for his brown tabby pelt
» 'Step' for his observant personality like a hawk and his graceful movements
----------------------------------------------------------------
╒══════════════════════════════════════╕
Whitefang
╘══════════════════════════════════════╛
» Whitefang is a short coated white she-cat with hard and unemotional yellow eyes. She has a large scar across her muzzle, across the bridge of her nose and tall rounded ears. She has a bright pink nose and large paws with a strong and muscular build, not very petite.
» Whitefang is a highly mysterious cat who doesn't care much for others. In fact, she downright hates them most of the time. Her past is unknown, so nobody really knows what made her this way. She has extreme trust issues and dislikes kits and liars. She does not like to reveal much about herself and would rather be left alone most of the time. She's extremely stubborn and often ignores others. She's a very hard-stoned cat, she doesn't listen well and defies the rules all the time. She is pretty care free, but will take bold actions. She's equally good at hunting and fighting.
» 'White' for her white pelt
» 'Fang' for her hunting and fighting skill and her sharp personality
----------------------------------------------------------------
╒══════════════════════════════════════╕
Dovecall
╘══════════════════════════════════════╛
» Dovecall is a gentle white she-cat with smooth, dark grey patches along her body and face. Her fur is long and flowing and she has a petite build, like she would knock right over with the slightest bit of wind. She has brilliant blue eyes full of spirit, jumping in the air and batting a bird to the ground.
» It is a sunny day inside of Dovecall. She is full of spirit, and very cheerful, although she can be rather hot-headed when she's angry; speaking up against others no matter how high the rank. She has a laid-back and relaxed personality, and she has a tendency to daydream. She tends to be rather clumsy as well. She's an excellent hunter, although she is slightly lacking in battle skills, but not so much so that she is a hindrance to her Clan. While her sister always tells her she should settle down and have kits, she has no intention of doing so, and wishes to serve as a warrior, not be stuck in the nursery. She has a cooing voice and has an ability to manipulate her voice only slightly to mimic a bird, but for a short time as it is not healthy for her throat. It is useful when hunting.
» 'Dove' for her white and grey pelt
» 'Call' for her ability to mimic a bird
----------------------------------------------------------------