ThornClan Discussion and Forms

[keylimecoyote]

I think I heard about Erin Hunter confirming that Moonflower was a mistake. I've never heard of Ambermoon and Harveymoon though, so maybe it's allowed as a suffix? Idk.

[cardboardteeth]

According to a video I watched(forgot the title), those names were mistakes? It's up to Pop tho

[Weredog]

although i personally do not agree with using moon in a cat's name, i say that bluemoon should be accepted. there is a cat with the prefix of Moon- who was accepted. as well as a Sun- cat. the sun is sacred to the clans just like the moon so to not allow one but allow the other wouldn't make sense

[cardboardteeth]

weren't there a bunch of 'sun-' in the books? it might just be me recalling other roleplays, though.

[keylimecoyote]

I think there was a sun? I also don't remember the sun being sacred but hey I'm only on the second series soooo
:backs away slowly:

[cardboardteeth]

actually, there's moonstorm. thinking pop accepted them, so yeah bluemoon is accepted.

[keylimecoyote]

Yeah, true. So I guess she'd be accepted then.

[cardboardteeth]

yep

[Weredog]

idk about the books, i haven't read a lot of them and hardly remember individual cats tbh.

the sun might not have specifically been mentioned as sacred, or maybe it was i dunno, but i just kinda assumed it was. the moon is treated as more sacred of course but why wouldn't the sun be too? it brings light and warmth and is basically just the opposite of the moon. if anything you would think that it would be held with higher reguard than the moon because of those things. this is all just sorta speculation on my part i suppose though

[keylimecoyote]

The moon is probably sacred because it comes out at night when the stars are out, and those are normally seen as the souls of their warrior ancestors. Since the stars don't come out in the day I guess it's just not important to them? Idk.