Deep Blue Adoptables

[Bunneh<3]

and what do you mean by "used in more than one Halloween critter"?

[TheScamperPony]

Hmmm.. hint three made me think of Spiderwick. 0.o So meh guess it honey! XD

Another guess would be hair/fur, although hint three doesn't go along with it. Hair looks colored, but it is actually clear when you look at it under a microscope! And it is everyday.... haha

[FlitterRayne]

Smoke maybe? EDITED TO ADD: The clear wrapper on a candy? XD

[Ekio]

Bummer, but no worries FlitterRayne ^_^ There are 11 halloween jars so far. Only two have been won. So plenty of games til Halloween!

and what do you mean by "used in more than one Halloween critter"?

Meaning that it's used in the "fact"(wives tale) not actually IN the creature ^_^ good question!

[FlitterRayne]

The clear wrapper on a candy? XD

[DharSii]

evil? x3

[Ekio]

Ok, last hint!

filling in one of the blanks for you.

If you feed it to a________they go back to their graves.

[DharSii]

zombie?

[Brisa]

Light?

[Ekio]

On the right track DharSii! Now what is the item you feed them?
{which I totally wouldnt recommend by the way......thats a good way to become one!}