[NEW!!!] "Is this a fair trade?" Thread [READ RULES]

[satyrn.]

should i take this? they're trading for a risk pet and there's a 1/4 chance it'll turn into the pps dog but i just want to make sure this looks okay to me even if that's what it does turn out as. thanks!

i wouldn't trade it until its done growing, i did that once and it turned out to be the one i really wanted and they wouldn't trade back. But its all up to you honestly.

i second this, waiting until it grows is so much better, then you know if the trade was fair

[lexa.]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=85460527&userid=815563&signature=QZRwVuYNQV25cV4UP1ayjw

They are definitely overpaying, right?

that’s major overpay. BA is only valued at about a sorbet and you can easily get a non for the UR strawberry

[.Aurora.]

hi! demand wise, does this look fair for almost all the zodaics?

any help would be greatly appreciated!

[Equineknox]

Is this fair? Thanks for any advice!
trades/viewtrade.php?id=85493308&userid=749889&signature=OedZuIpQcbFv86-wGxdWlg

[Guest]

should i take this? they're trading for a risk pet and there's a 1/4 chance it'll turn into the pps dog but i just want to make sure this looks okay to me even if that's what it does turn out as. thanks!

i wouldn't trade it until its done growing, i did that once and it turned out to be the one i really wanted and they wouldn't trade back. But its all up to you honestly.

i second this, waiting until it grows is so much better, then you know if the trade was fair

This is massive overpay for any outcome, I would take it

[lexa.]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=85437767&userid=843624&signature=aNFWzSsSt0vXtHjoBplMrQ

Was this fair to me?

[SpiritX]

Are any of these fair? New player here trying to figure out 18th December logic -w-

trades/viewtrade.php?id=85451949&userid=981441&signature=YqT_VPgkufpQA-b2QeWniA

trades/viewtrade.php?id=85482500&userid=981441&signature=AeLVy1SUuSkoMvfTVqzRjQ

trades/viewtrade.php?id=85485209&userid=981441&signature=-tAR3WYKqOPbBorTQfzN_w

trades/viewtrade.php?id=85485209&userid=981441&signature=-tAR3WYKqOPbBorTQfzN_w

[silvermahogany]

Does this look fair?

This one too, i feel like theyre overpaying- xxx

[pique]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=85518550&userid=602182&signature=w87exqMu1i-0RzXbyoQLFQ

trades/viewtrade.php?id=85533538&userid=602182&signature=3q-vgVLVzO12jzt1uBWnIQ

How are these trades? No idea what the others' pets are worth!

I saw both are unfair Tess horses can go for a lot but so can the Corgis I say it's unfair on your side but I'd make sure to get second opinions!

Thank you! Should I accept the Tess Horse one then?

[DarkestWerewolf]

Received this offer for my 54 store pet auction. I’m considering to auto it but I want to be sure first.
Personally, would you take it? I understand store pets are valuable as they will no longer be available but URs can still be attainable every Dec 18 so I’m kind of on the fence for this. Would love multiple opinions from various players if possible
Link to group

i whole heartedly do not think this is fair to you
i understand urs are valuable but to offer the single newest ur for all those store pets seems unfair.

the demand on the store pets is so well because youre right, theyre unatainable after theyre gone
so i wouldnt take it

Thank you so much!
Would appreciate more thoughts on this as well if possible c:
If it makes it easier to analyse my group, I can break it down. There are 4 complete sets, couple of high demand pets like the pps dragon cat, dinos, alpaca, kitsune & kirins