The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread [notice pg. 457]

[Wolf's Spirit]

Isn't this overpay for the person offering quantity? I thought it was... The person I was trading with told me otherwise...

well it depends on how much the owner wants to keep the pet ((I know A LOT of people who would do anything for that pet/never give it up)) but i would say its little bit over pay, maybe remove 1-2 pets that are rare ((and are a recent date, the oldest pets are the most to value in my opinion)) but keep the very rares... i'm not quite sure this one is a bit tricky, I would have to say try to get very rares/rare pets that are in the same date range((if you have any)). Otherwise i would wait until someone else responds to this trade

This thread is not made for advice given on personal opinion, but based on rarity (although sometimes on demand also). Please do not give uneducated advice.

As for the trade, it looks about fair, although given some demand based on rats it could be a little unfair to the top. I don't believe it is overpay on the quantity side though.

Thank you Fat Unicorn told me about 4 '09 rates would be fair for an orange punk dog, so I thought this would be overpay considering the vr rat is a '09 re-release...

[TheBeautifulDarkness]

Is this fair? Thanks and if not what could even it out? Also is it fair demand wise. http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... lqY-uuI-NA

[gluue]

K, thanks , what about

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=24920304&userid=417176&signature=1u7oC8i8AMXwIqqDukcWMg

Hrm...

[Demonking Urizen]

K, thanks , what about

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=24920304&userid=417176&signature=1u7oC8i8AMXwIqqDukcWMg

I would fair demand-wise. The Shima has lost some demand since all people are crazy about the August PPS.

Is this fair? Thanks and if not what could even it out? Also is it fair demand wise. http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... lqY-uuI-NA

I think it's unfair. The target dog is 2 tier lower than the pink patchy - I am not sure how many '09 rares are needed to get used with the tiers, but the common items don't make this trade fair.

[gluue]

Thankyou!

[Shiro Okami Kokoro]

Is this fair? Thanks and if not what could even it out? Also is it fair demand wise. http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... lqY-uuI-NA

I think it's unfair. The target dog is 2 tier lower than the pink patchy - I am not sure how many '09 rares are needed to get used with the tiers, but the common items don't make this trade fair.

Disregarding the items, since I have no idea about their worth, it would take about 15 '09 Rares to fill the gap. Or, 2 mid advents and an '09 Rare.

[Etruuco]

I keep getting mixed responses about this trade so I'd like another opinion. ^^

Is this fair with factoring in rarity and demand?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... -cnazdwlOA

[Shiro Okami Kokoro]

I keep getting mixed responses about this trade so I'd like another opinion. ^^

Is this fair with factoring in rarity and demand?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... -cnazdwlOA

I'm not sure about demand, but I believe that's slightly on the unfair side to you.

[Etruuco]

I keep getting mixed responses about this trade so I'd like another opinion. ^^

Is this fair with factoring in rarity and demand?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... -cnazdwlOA

I'm not sure about demand, but I believe that's slightly on the unfair side to you.

Thanks for the quick response! Do you know what should be added to make it more fair to me?

[November.Fox]

I keep getting mixed responses about this trade so I'd like another opinion. ^^

Is this fair with factoring in rarity and demand?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... -cnazdwlOA

Technically, I believe that's unfair to them rarity wise. (It is only a bottom tier advent. Only worth about 3 - 4 {Possibly 5?} '09 rares if I'm recalling correctly) But since the Marionette has demand, I'm not sure demand wise. You'll want another opinion xD