The "Is this a fair trade?" thread

[DustyZoiveon]

Is this fair? I don't know if I should accept or not. The amount of very commons is worrisome, but they are offering a lot, so idk.

[skelliursa]

xxx

Could I have some help on this trade please ?

Personally I wouldn’t take it. The halo on the item guide was looked over in November 2016 thus it has been 2 years and items aren’t rereleased. If we go by the 2016 value each one is worth a mid-September list which is worth I would say 5 midadvents thus the halos alone are worth 15 midadvents. The pocky could go for a couple ‘09 rares each. Due to the amount of quantity of the items that are rare, I would say it is unfair to you.

Thank you so much ! I appreciate the feedback. =)

[Fertseshoy Getes]

Hello! What need to be added? Thank you!
Can they add stores to make the trade fair? Which year and how much?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=73167854&userid=858381&signature=ywlMxIs1roVFOMRnLNFMqw

[serik]

Is this fair?? Also is the halo the ‘08 halo?? Thanks for any help ^^

[popping star]

Is this fair?? Also is the halo the ‘08 halo?? Thanks for any help ^^

It's unfair to you. The UR lion is worth a non + a green toxic, and it goes for fair trades.
Their side roughly equals to a bit more than a sorbet. (The C$ is worth slightly more than the green toxic tier.)
Yes, that is the '08 halo. It goes for a mid September list, but it doesn't cover the gap.
The halo doesn't bring their side up to the blue toxic tier, so their side still equals to a bit more than a sorbet.

[Kina202]

is this fair? thanks!

[broccolibomp!]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=73170083&userid=782848&signature=-w_5EzjAB1OPHVtbRw6VrQ would this be fair, taking into account demand? ive heard the cs 1st bday dog usually goes for underpay. thank you!

[Mythz]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=73170083&userid=782848&signature=-w_5EzjAB1OPHVtbRw6VrQ would this be fair, taking into account demand? ive heard the cs 1st bday dog usually goes for underpay. thank you!

I believe this is unfair to them - you're pet is a normal, 08 or 09 VR, while theirs is a September list - worth 14-16 09 rares ^^

[Joof]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=73170083&userid=782848&signature=-w_5EzjAB1OPHVtbRw6VrQ would this be fair, taking into account demand? ive heard the cs 1st bday dog usually goes for underpay. thank you!

Way unfair to them. The grinner is worth two mid advents and a '09 rare while your dog isn't even worth a low advent list.
Grinners go for fair trades, I never had underpay for any of the ones I owned and I have seen lots of trades valuing them at their list place. It's just a false rumour spread around (:

[rainfall.]

hello! i've got a quick question
is the ur bengal going for a sorbet demand wise? also, would that be fair rarity wise? if not, what would the bengal side have to add?
thank you! <3