The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Elettra]

Is this trade unfair to the other person?

Yes. Cakes from sept. list, but Skeleton PPS - Big gap and worth more. + Cakes have not a very good demand.
+ Their Skeleton PPS is truedated. Your Cake dog - rereleased.

Agreed that this is unfair to the skele PPS, but please do not give out false advice. The skele PPS is not a true date. ^^ It is from December 18th of 2008. While it is very close to the original release date (October 2008), it is not a true date. Also, there is no difference in value in terms of a rereleased pet versus a true date. Some people prefer true dates, but they are worth the same.

[Eagle's Eye]

I'm offered this guy for my grey malk dragon. What does it usually go for? Has anyone had experience trading one away? Would you take this offer?

[Pug;]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=63111828&userid=854402&signature=oEKCqpTtkMQfI4MK9PfGcQ
Hey! could we please get awnsers quickly, is this fair to me?

[LovelyRita]

does this equal around 2 nons for my dogtag? I value the zonkey at around 1 non. If it doesn't add up what would have to be added?

[hummxs]

I'm offered this guy for my grey malk dragon. What does it usually go for? Has anyone had experience trading one away? Would you take this offer?

I personally wouldn't take it since it's hard to trade them off. It has bad demand. Rarity-wise they'd be overpaying I believe since the GMD is high on the September list while the Purple Horse is low on the Main List. I think this trade is up to you~

[Silphy]

Is this fair? Should I accept c:

[HimikoToga]

Is this fair? Please take Rarity and Demand into consideration. If it's unfair, what needs to be added/removed and to which side?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... Jw4Qu_bdzQ

Is this fair as well? I don't usually do item trades.
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... RNFM5jAEMw

Is this somewhat fair considering demand? I know that I'm overpaying, but by how much?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... MuSfZ79oTg

[Zacharie]

Hey, please help me w/ these three trades! Thanks a bunch to anyone who helps

1

2

3 - this one says they can add a spotted tribal as well.

I know they're all overpay, but given the raven's inflated demand I'm unsure of what to accept/edit.
Can I have a second opinion?

EDIT: also got this http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... M50AFnOKiw
And a trade offering a blue toxic for the raven- I'm on mobile currently and can't get both links, sorry!

[Eevee]

is this fair for my scarf? I am not sure how much it's worth. Any help is very much appreciated!

[HimikoToga]

Is this fair? Please take Rarity and Demand into consideration. If it's unfair, what needs to be added/removed and to which side?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... Jw4Qu_bdzQ

Is this fair as well? I don't usually do item trades.
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... RNFM5jAEMw

Is this somewhat fair considering demand? I know that I'm overpaying, but by how much?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... MuSfZ79oTg