The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[lady gaga]

could i have some opinions on these trades? Demand wise, please.

Second opinions on above? (Valuing Raven ~non, mostly curious about demand on marionettes/patchworks)

Also, I know the zonkey isn't placed, but is this fair based on demand? I know the cinnamon bun goes for nons, what about this one?

[black water]

thoughts on this? which side needs to add, and how much? thanks in advance!

[Hive_Mentality]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... cjxqaMKVFw Is this fair?

[Elettra]

Thoughts? Would you personally accept? Thank you! (:

I would never accept that! It seems way too unfair. A 2016 in exchange for a 2008 and 2009? Noooope.

The pets are actually list pets, and the 2016 they are offering is a re-release from 2008.

Second opinion please?

[Reirin]

Thoughts? Would you personally accept? Thank you! (:

I would never accept that! It seems way too unfair. A 2016 in exchange for a 2008 and 2009? Noooope.

I disagree. The dog on their side is a tier 7 advent (re-released in 2016) worth 7-8 '09 rares. Your two tier 1 advents are worth 3-4 each, so your side adds up to 6-8 '09 rares. I'd say it's fair, but feel free to get another opinion!

[musicgurl333]

Thoughts? Would you personally accept? Thank you! (:

I would never accept that! It seems way too unfair. A 2016 in exchange for a 2008 and 2009? Noooope.

I don't know whether or not it's fair, but the dog on the top is a rerelease pet. It's nice that you want to help, but it's important to make sure you're giving knowlagable advice.

[tealfanta]

is this fair? if not what needs to be added? thank you in advance!

[Elettra]

Thoughts? Would you personally accept? Thank you! (:

I would never accept that! It seems way too unfair. A 2016 in exchange for a 2008 and 2009? Noooope.

I disagree. The dog on their side is a tier 7 advent (re-released in 2016) worth 7-8 '09 rares. Your two tier 1 advents are worth 3-4 each, so your side adds up to 6-8 '09 rares. I'd say it's fair, but feel free to get another opinion!

Thank you! Would you personally accept?

[shisho]

thoughts on this? which side needs to add, and how much? thanks in advance!

Peppermint eared is worth 6-7 09' rares, so
4 17' store pets = 2 09' rares (late)
2 16' store pets = 1 09' rare (mid)
4 15' store pets = 2 09' rares (early)
You need to add around 1-2 09' rares, i don't think the commons/uncommons add up to one 09' rare.

[lady gaga]

could i have some opinions on these trades? Demand wise, please.

Second opinions on above? (Valuing Raven ~non, mostly curious about demand on marionettes/patchworks)

Also, I know the zonkey isn't placed, but is this fair based on demand? I know the cinnamon bun goes for nons, what about this one?