The "Is this a fair trade?" thread

[skyline]

would this be too much for an ur tiger or around fair?

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 03IPEEaLWw

Far too much, the tiger is written as being worth 5 nons. Demand, however, is user based and it does trade over it's own value sometimes. Still, I wouldn't go that far over.

it's true that demand is user based, but regardless it'll rule the trade over rarity, and in
the sense it's best to give advice from demand more so if it does get more than it's worth
so the user doesn't end up getting less than they could, as that does sound kind of greedy,
it's just how the site works. so for the trade personally, i'd say you're overpaying just a
bit, if at all. the tiger goes for 8-9 nons, your side adds up to about 9-10 with demand so
it just depends on how you value the tiger, and if you're both happy with the trade c:

[Animall]

Thanks for all of the help, however I have been having an easy time getting trade offers for my cinnabun for 2 nons (coontail tier) and it has been quite easy to get offers for it, it’s my pet that most people trade for the most. With this in mind, would anyone say something different?

I support my claim with this link, as I went through a similar issue the other day, and I was helped a lot by multiple people :)
If you are getting offers worth 2 nons on your cinnabun, I definitely would not accept this trade. At most, if we really want to push it, the eat me/drink me SET can go for 2 nons.

EDIT: fixed the link to the right page of discussion

[Overhaul]

Please help! Is this fair for my pps gryphon?

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... CUVNR3FmhQ

[3000feet]

Would this be fair in exchange for a blue toxic?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... D1pnRQ1c3g


And how about this? 'm not sure how many store pet are needed to equal an advent list.
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... pom0IP_cHQ

[chuuya nakahara]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=72978387&userid=661008&signature=kHQuhMPBsPEkrKl2F6rtpw

Is this fair?

[gudetama]

Here is the trade....


is it fair to me? idk what needs to be added to the other side?

[leonastefani]

Is this trade fair?

Thank you for any help!

[skyline]

could i get an opinion on this?
i'm not too sure what the eat me's demand is like at the moment
i really appreciate any opinions!! <3

[gudetama]

could i get an opinion on this?
i'm not too sure what the eat me's demand is like at the moment
i really appreciate any opinions!! <3

@animall already answered your questions so im going to copy and paste their answer:

The eat me alone is worth one sorb, and the joker goes for 1 non. I would swap the joker for the set, but not for one. I wouldnt take this. Although the eat me CAN go for a non, realistically its not worth that at all and its only greed that amps up the "price," mainly because of false advice given on this thread. I had the same question the other day, so I hope this helps: search.php?st=0&sk=t&sd=d&sr=posts&keywords=eat+me&t=3790990&sf=msgonly&ch=-1&start=10

[skyline]

could i get an opinion on this?
i'm not too sure what the eat me's demand is like at the moment
i really appreciate any opinions!! <3

@animall already answered your questions so im going to copy and paste their answer:

The eat me alone is worth one sorb, and the joker goes for 1 non. I would swap the joker for the set, but not for one. I wouldnt take this. Although the eat me CAN go for a non, realistically its not worth that at all and its only greed that amps up the "price," mainly because of false advice given on this thread. I had the same question the other day, so I hope this helps: search.php?st=0&sk=t&sd=d&sr=posts&keywords=eat+me&t=3790990&sf=msgonly&ch=-1&start=10

oh my apologies i must've not seen it, i thought i'd checked every page.
my apologies again, thank you @animall !!