The "Is This a Fair Trade?" Thread

[*Nevi Nova*]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=43704331&userid=5648&signature=q1UXupHP5VrshZ6pGBu0nQ

I just got sent that trade. I need to know if it's fair to me (the bottom).

unfair to them by a bit ^.^

To which side? Saying to them isn't saying anything. Which side... top or bottom? Half of my pets they want are more than the 3 month rule. I need EXPERIENCED players to answer for me.

its unfair to the penguins,and actully they are all in the 3 month rule the penguins have more demand and 2 very commons dont = a common

[PenguinQueen]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=43704331&userid=5648&signature=q1UXupHP5VrshZ6pGBu0nQ

I just got sent that trade. I need to know if it's fair to me (the bottom).

unfair to them by a bit ^.^

To which side? Saying to them isn't saying anything. Which side... top or bottom? Half of my pets they want are more than the 3 month rule. I need EXPERIENCED players to answer for me.

Unfair to the penguins.
The very commons don't make up a common.
(Normally when the person answering says "Them", it means not you, but your trading partner.)

[~ Tayrisha ~]

Joker + BA + ??? = July PPS

What would make this fair, please?
Or is BA + Joker enough for July PPS?

around 2 nons i believe get a second option on that
but a joker and a BA dont add up even with the demand it would be still unfair

Thanks. Someone second opinion, please? ^^

[Midnight Wanderer]

Yeah, you're probably asking, why do you want someone to check on this?

[ｗｏｌｆ ｓｏｎｇ.]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=43704331&userid=5648&signature=q1UXupHP5VrshZ6pGBu0nQ

I just got sent that trade. I need to know if it's fair to me (the bottom).

To which side? Saying to them isn't saying anything. Which side... top or bottom? Half of my pets they want are more than the 3 month rule. I need EXPERIENCED players to answer for me.

its unfair to the penguins,and actully they are all in the 3 month rule the penguins have more demand and 2 very commons dont = a common

it depends on how many very commons the player thinks is worth a common
keep in mind that the rarity of the vcs might not be the same worth to you as another player. there is not a defined answer on how many very commons are a common

[.always.]

demand wise, fair to me? http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 94zCINX4TA

neither horses or butterfly wolves have much demand, so its still unfair to them ^.^

Thank you! Second opinion?

[*Nevi Nova*]

which one of thease should i accept? http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... ao0Wv6ot5Q
or http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... GgWyT2Iq1A

in the first one i know the lime ice rat is higher on the September list then flower/toxic rat but then i dunno if what there offering even adds up to the lime ice rat (so.....which is better?

halpp

[nice]

could I get a rough estimate on how much these items are worth?

thanks!

Roughly 29 '09 rares, so unfair to you

thanks! What about this? and could I also get an idea of what should be added or removed? ^u^

[Angelx3]

which one of thease should i accept? http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... ao0Wv6ot5Q
or http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... GgWyT2Iq1A

in the first one i know the lime ice rat is higher on the September list then flower/toxic rat but then i dunno if what there offering even adds up to the lime ice rat (so.....which is better?

halpp

it doesnt add up the gap the first one is a lot more valuable

[PenguinQueen]

which one of thease should i accept? http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... ao0Wv6ot5Q
or http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... GgWyT2Iq1A

in the first one i know the lime ice rat is higher on the September list then flower/toxic rat but then i dunno if what there offering even adds up to the lime ice rat (so.....which is better?

halpp

I would take the one with the lime ice rat. Your can tell which is worth more If you look at the rares list Guide.
Plus the store pet does not make up the gap between the two list rats.