The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Peppermint Mist]

Hello! Is this a fair trade?
Thanks in advance!

[Artisys]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... xUaV5lg9Fg

this one surprised me as I have really wanted that pet for awhile, but I want to see if it's a fair trade or not. :3

[moonbeam.]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... xUaV5lg9Fg

this one surprised me as I have really wanted that pet for awhile, but I want to see if it's a fair trade or not. :3

Unfair to you by a non, the Raven Dog only goes by a non, yours is only worth 2 nons.
I suggest a second opinion though.

[niko.]

Hello! May I get an opinion on this trade? I know the bee has good demand but I'm not sure what it goes for. Would I be able to get the quantity back? Is it worth trading my rose set?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... QrEyUsDUdA

In my opinion, I dont think its worth it. The rose pps has the same or even higher demand. The 2008 target dog vr alone is still probably worth more than the bee, even if the bee is omgsr, because of its value. I wouldnt accept- especially because several of your side are list pets with high demand. You could probably get overpay for the rose set (or even part of it) if you find the right person. Demandwise, I dont think its very fair. Raritywise and looking at the dates, it looks like an overtrade. But you might want a second opinion on this~

[Horror]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... xUaV5lg9Fg

this one surprised me as I have really wanted that pet for awhile, but I want to see if it's a fair trade or not. :3

Unfair to you by a non, the Raven Dog only goes by a non, yours is only worth 2 nons.
I suggest a second opinion though.

The ravens demand has died and it really just goes up to a sorbet tier or around that

[sunzie]

Hows this trade?
Click

[Elettra]

Hello! May I get an opinion on this trade? I know the bee has good demand but I'm not sure what it goes for. Would I be able to get the quantity back? Is it worth trading my rose set?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... QrEyUsDUdA

In my opinion, I dont think its worth it. The rose pps has the same or even higher demand. The 2008 target dog vr alone is still probably worth more than the bee, even if the bee is omgsr, because of its value. I wouldnt accept- especially because several of your side are list pets with high demand. You could probably get overpay for the rose set (or even part of it) if you find the right person. Demandwise, I dont think its very fair. Raritywise and looking at the dates, it looks like an overtrade. But you might want a second opinion on this~

I'm sorry, but please don't give false advice. ^^
The target dog by itself is nowhere near worth the value of the bee. The bee is worth 2 nons and the target dog is worth a light leopard (low september list) and an '09 rare, much, much less than even half of the value of the bee.

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... xUaV5lg9Fg

this one surprised me as I have really wanted that pet for awhile, but I want to see if it's a fair trade or not. :3

Unfair to you by a non, the Raven Dog only goes by a non, yours is only worth 2 nons.
I suggest a second opinion though.

The ravens demand has died and it really just goes up to a sorbet tier or around that

Agreed. The July PPS is worth about 2 nons, and while the raven (with its extremely high demand) used to get around a non, I haven't seen that for awhile. Typically, I've been seeing about the equivalent of a sorbet, maybe less for the raven. If you value the raven at a sorbet, the trade would be unfair to you by about 1 non and 2 sorbets. If you value the raven at a non, it would be unfair to you by a non. c:

[Jiloon]

Hello! May I get an opinion on this trade? I know the bee has good demand but I'm not sure what it goes for. Would I be able to get the quantity back? Is it worth trading my rose set?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... QrEyUsDUdA

In my opinion, I dont think its worth it. The rose pps has the same or even higher demand. The 2008 target dog vr alone is still probably worth more than the bee, even if the bee is omgsr, because of its value. I wouldnt accept- especially because several of your side are list pets with high demand. You could probably get overpay for the rose set (or even part of it) if you find the right person. Demandwise, I dont think its very fair. Raritywise and looking at the dates, it looks like an overtrade. But you might want a second opinion on this~

Please don't give false advice, that could lead someone to accepting a super unfair trade :c

The trade is unfair to them. The UR Aussie has average or low demand, and needs two Sorbets worth to add up to the next tier, the UR Bee. The rest of your side doesn't add up to even one Sorbet, so they're overpaying by a lot, especially since the UR Bee has good demand c:

[moonbeam.]

Hello! May I get an opinion on this trade? I know the bee has good demand but I'm not sure what it goes for. Would I be able to get the quantity back? Is it worth trading my rose set?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... QrEyUsDUdA

In my opinion, I dont think its worth it. The rose pps has the same or even higher demand. The 2008 target dog vr alone is still probably worth more than the bee, even if the bee is omgsr, because of its value. I wouldnt accept- especially because several of your side are list pets with high demand. You could probably get overpay for the rose set (or even part of it) if you find the right person. Demandwise, I dont think its very fair. Raritywise and looking at the dates, it looks like an overtrade. But you might want a second opinion on this~

I'm sorry, but please don't give false advice. ^^
The target dog by itself is nowhere near worth the value of the bee. The bee is worth 2 nons and the target dog is worth a light leopard (low september list) and an '09 rare, much, much less than even half of the value of the bee.

I agree, I find this trade unfair to the bee since the bee is worth 2 nons and I don't think the trade fills up the gap for the bee.

[Artisys]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... bktWVzETBw

I'm getting a real lot of trades for it lol. I just want to find a trade that is fair tho, and tho i do like alot of the pets that are shown, i want to make sure its fair enough on both sides... XP :T