The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Faux]

Is this fair for the cerberus?

Trade

red cer is 2-3 nons so its 2.5-3 worth so its up to you

edit: HOLD UP, thats a dog tag not a non dog. dog tag is 1.5-2+ 1 non so thats already max 3 so their over

Generally the Cerb gets 3-4 Nons rather than 2-3, but I suppose it'd depend on who you're trading with. Their side consists of the Dogtag (1.5 - 2, usually 1.5) + a Non + Red X Dog (2 MAs) + Jabberwocky(?) (1 MA) + Jackalope (1 MA) + Carousel Horse (1 MA) which in addition to the bulk is at least 3 so honestly it's up to how you price the bulk

[Faux]

hi is this trade fair? thanks <3

Although their pet is a Re-release, if you don't really care about it it's originally from Christmas of 2009 which is outside of the 3 month range but if you don't mind then I think it's a pretty okay swap

[Faux]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=91129103&userid=724816&signature=6N9KzbiCK6DXPNCqEg-S5A

is this fair? they said they could add a few more rare butterfly wolves (i'm collecting them)

edit: i got another cheetah trade

trades/viewtrade.php?id=91129817&userid=724816&signature=QFR_ovgFZm-5bK6Lvd-Rpg

The first one's more fair to you since they're only trading for 3 of the 4 cheetahs, although only if you value your cheetahs at only 1 09' rare each

[allynabean]

hfkgdfs im getting so many trades rn aa
does this one here and also this one seem fair aa????

[sunfloweer]

could you rate these out of 10 for my auction?
i feel like i would give it a 5/10 but im not sure of the value of the snowman cat

and this one

also dis one ^-^

- sunfloweer ^^

[racoonie2004]

nevermind it got cancelled

[1209lin]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=91124723&userid=463302&signature=teTuPnn8PYJp9fXSo49tRA

Is this trade fair? Thanks in advance

[Shado]

Hello again! Is this a fair trade? I almost instinctually declined it because two of my favorite pets are in it! (The skeleton cat and the Cheetah. I'm personally demanding overpay for my store pets that i only have one of, the cheetah being one of those!)

Also how about this trade too?

[Opalserpent]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=91129420&userid=979818&signature=4qGbhO-RPeVBHcn2fWkhdA
Fair or nah? If not, which side is it unfair to, and how can it be balanced out?

[kjzq]

Hello again! Is this a fair trade? I almost instinctually declined it because two of my favorite pets are in it! (The skeleton cat and the Cheetah. I'm personally demanding overpay for my store pets that i only have one of, the cheetah being one of those!)

Rarity-wise, they are underpaying. The rares and store pet on their side do not add up to yours, and the uncommons aren’t a fair swap. Demand-wise, rats and monkeys are significantly harder to trade away than store pets and popular halloween pets (the cat), so you’d have a much better shot at keeping your side. I’d recommend getting a second opinion though.