The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[The Fifth Spirit]

Would UR Peach + Sorbet = July PPS?

Unfair to the PPS, I believe. One Non is worth 3 sorbets, and the July PPS is worth 2 Nons, or 6 sorbs. The Peach is worth anywhere from 2 Sorbs to a Non (actual value hasn’t been decided yet), so its worth 2-3 sorbs. The Peach side would equal 3-4 Sorbets total, which is, at the very least, 2 sorbs short of the July PPS’s worth.

[Cerrik]

Is this fair and would you personally accept it?
Trade

[sunstream.]

[quote="violet!"][quote="violet!"][quote="violet!"][quote="violet!"]

how about now?

This trade is fair c: your store pets are good demand, though, so have em add

[Safarian]

REALLY URGENT!

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... tkqVegiepw

[Cerrik]

Is this fair and would you personally accept it?
Trade

[~GirlsDeMo~]

I'd like a couple opinions demand wise (Pup is Rose PPS) since I've never owned a list Malk dragon.

[OriGalaxii]

how about now?

my trading skills are so rusty, sorry for commenting so much.

c:

I’d really like to trade with this person so would appreciate any help

I believe it should be fair, since I've seen people value store pets from before 2015 as late 2009 rares

[dibidibidis]

I would still appreciate any comments about this (My nonballoon for their pickle)!

How bad is the Pickle's demand? What's the highest I can hope to get with it, relatively easily?

Thanks in advance!

[The Fifth Spirit]

Is this fair and would you personally accept it?
Trade

They’re offering a tier 9 Advent pet, which is worth 8-9 ‘09 rares. Your Shima isn’t a list pet, but it can go for low-mid advents due to demand. They’re offeirng a high Advent for it, which is significant overpay. Whether you accept it or not depends on what you value the Shima at.

[sunstream.]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=69821455&userid=901245&signature=DTfp-1knLOxpXN_RaE2jjA
Do I need to add something?

No, you're overpaying to begin with ^^ They need to add