The "Is This a Fair Trade?" Thread -READ 2ND POST-

[EverGnar]

Obviously very unfair to me by date. What would you say what they are offering is worth? Does it add up to one of the rares they want? http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=36790809&userid=147040&signature=svZMQ6KUFzwZCLq5GCp2fQ

Demand: unfair to you
Rarity: unfair to them
Date : unfair to you

{ They're not asking if is unfair, they already know that ^^

@EverGnar: I would say the two 2012 pets could be worth your 2010 Uncommon, and the others might add up to a 2011 Uncommon. Please get a second opinion though, as I may have done my rarity math wrong.

Thank you very much. c:
That second opinion would be great.

I'm also curious about a trade that would be my UR purple horse for their grey malk dragon.
Considering the demand of each pet, does that seem reasonable?

[canadianhowl]

This fair
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... Y9ehVGj5ew

Can someone please help me?

[PenguinQueen]

This fair
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... Y9ehVGj5ew

Can someone please help me?

Looks unfair to them

[HeartOfCoal]

Could I get some help with some item trades?


To which side is it unfair, and why?
What needs to be added to make this fair?


Thank you so, so much to anyone who can help!!

[~ t r o u b l e ~]

Obviously very unfair to me by date. What would you say what they are offering is worth? Does it add up to one of the rares they want? http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=36790809&userid=147040&signature=svZMQ6KUFzwZCLq5GCp2fQ

Demand: unfair to you
Rarity: unfair to them
Date : unfair to you

not sure what the difference between date and rarity is seeing as fairness counts on dates and rarity.
unfair to the bottom in every aspect
keep the uncommon on your side and add a 2012 rare to your side.

This fair
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... Y9ehVGj5ew

Can someone please help me?

unfair to them

[.swan.]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... HjnSCRDqdg
is this fair?

[~ t r o u b l e ~]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... HjnSCRDqdg
is this fair?

unless I missed a mainlist pet, its unfair to you

[gallifrey falls.]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... HjnSCRDqdg
is this fair?

{ I would say no, unless I missed a high List pet in the trade. A few of those pets in the trade do have good demand(ie August PPS and Shima). I got a 6th Tier Mainlist for my August PPS when I traded it, but it's up to you whether you take the trade down.
By Lists: Unfair to you
By Demand: Slightly more fair, depending on how you value certain pets.

[Lee-Sins]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... HjnSCRDqdg
is this fair?

{ I would say no, unless I missed a high List pet in the trade. A few of those pets in the trade do have good demand(ie August PPS and Shima). I got a 6th Tier Mainlist for my August PPS when I traded it, but it's up to you whether you take the trade down.
By Lists: Unfair to you
By Demand: Slightly more fair, depending on how you value certain pets.

The blue toxic is above the sorbets on the main list ^^; majority of the pets they offered have some good demand and others not so much (as the horses/rats etc have little to no demand). Even the demand of the shima and the august pps lion wouldn't cut it close to fair ^^;

[gallifrey falls.]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... HjnSCRDqdg
is this fair?

{ I would say no, unless I missed a high List pet in the trade. A few of those pets in the trade do have good demand(ie August PPS and Shima). I got a 6th Tier Mainlist for my August PPS when I traded it, but it's up to you whether you take the trade down.
By Lists: Unfair to you
By Demand: Slightly more fair, depending on how you value certain pets.

The blue toxic is above the sorbets on the main list ^^; majority of the pets they offered have some good demand and others not so much (as the horses/rats etc have little to no demand). Even the demand of the shima and the august pps lion wouldn't cut it close to fair ^^;

{ Oh, my bad then! Yes, I don't think the August Lion and Shima would do much for them in the trade then. Unfair by all fronts now, thank you for pointing the out wynter ^^