The "Is this a fair trade?" thread

[popping star]

Can I have opinions on these trades for my liontail + lolita?
UR peach (I'm unsure of what it commonly goes for.)
UR malk
non-coon
lolita for sorbet

odd eye's trades (used for tracking, don't delete.)

[dakotapaws]

how fair does this look?

and this one?

could i have some help please?

[comcom123]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=73205241&userid=225732&signature=VHCdgqvMC43kK8ADkiTSVA

What's the fairness of this trade? I don't really know item worth but this. Seems a bit uneven to me. I'd love a second opinion and what could balance this.

Edit:
After checking, they are asking for every single one of my items in exchange for five rares.

I'd really appreciate some help

[FOUND VERDICT]

Can I have opinions on these trades for my liontail + lolita?
UR peach (I'm unsure of what it commonly goes for.)
UR malk
non-coon
lolita for sorbet

odd eye's trades (used for tracking, don't delete.)

the peach was recently placed on the list, one tier under the non.
so the peach/non/malk are all pretty much going for the same, although the malk would be the better option demandwise in my opinion..

both the liontail and lolita go for an sorbet, so technically all 3 offers are overpaying with around an sorbet
if you are looking for quantity lower lists, i personally would stick with the store listpets though

[popping star]

Can I have opinions on these trades for my liontail + lolita?
UR peach (I'm unsure of what it commonly goes for.)
UR malk
non-coon
lolita for sorbet

odd eye's trades (used for tracking, don't delete.)

the peach was recently placed on the list, one tier under the non.
so the peach/non/malk are all pretty much going for the same, although the malk would be the better option demandwise in my opinion..

both the liontail and lolita go for an sorbet, so technically all 3 offers are overpaying with around an sorbet
if you are looking for quantity lower lists, i personally would stick with the store listpets though

Ah, thank you!

[danijust]

Hello! Is this fair? trades/viewtrade.php?id=73205608&userid=818001&signature=5Hki_4xFY_sCygrtjE5gbA

[Zombilon]

Hello! Is this fair? trades/viewtrade.php?id=73205608&userid=818001&signature=5Hki_4xFY_sCygrtjE5gbA

Unfair to you. ^^
Your side is equal to over seven 2015 rares. They're only offering six 2015 rares in exchange.
You would need to take of one 2015 rare, a 2017 rare, and a 2018 rare from your side for this to be fair to you.

[danijust]

Thanks for the help!

[Mythz]

Is this fair?
How about this?
I'm not sure if the Moon Tree dog has any demand?
Thank you <3

[FOUND VERDICT]

Is this fair?
How about this?
I'm not sure if the Moon Tree dog has any demand?
Thank you <3

both are unfair to you, even without demand.
the moon tree dog does have good demand, it can go for an '09 rare or a bit more from my personal experience.