The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[TooSpooky]

just got this bid, I feel like this is really good but can I get another opinion? Thanks

[Mastema-Rastus]

Would love some advice! Thank you in advance!
trades/viewtrade.php?id=111320930&userid=989789&signature=9OZhUjhtZ0SSBgpJvYnC9A

[fuyunofabuki]

I would love a second opinion on this, it’s an auction I want to enter (I sent the trade as a suggestion because of the value of the pet I was offering I’m pretty sure is a bit over on my side I just wanted to get some second opinions as they are estimating their side at about 1.8NONs, while my ur pastel is 3NONs according to horrors list. I’d just like it If someone could double check their side of things.

trades/viewtrade.php?id=111320983&userid=948125&signature=nFkKMzEp_MfgWymbg_7fWQ

I actually counted a bit higher than that haha, closer to 2nons or a bit more for their side. They've got many great pets there but also some fodder that will be harder to trade if you don't want to keep the pets, especially the rare rats and horses. They may be worth something rarity wise but that's a huge demand gap you should be aware of.

Ultimately, it's really unfair to the UR Pastel. I get wanting to trade for bulk though. I feel like if they wanted to add another 3-4MA even it'd feel better.

I do get wanting to trade down a pet that big! Haha. I actually did the same thing closer to when the UR Pastel came out, I really thought the worth wouldn't stay at 3non and would drop. I traded for something around the same value as this trade but it was for bulk store pets and I did end up keeping quite a few of the pets.

For reference:
trades/viewtrade.php?id=104727911&userid=296382&signature=5BS_Jowf5fjks_2ndbXwHA

So I get wanting bulk even if it's unfair lol. Can't advise it on this thread but I get it!!

Anyways best of luck to you in whatever you do! ♥️

Thank you!

[voe]

is this a fair offer for cerberus?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=111320341&userid=70994&signature=Go9Uipjq9RYnHOUZM_bjVA

Their offer is about 6 non so I would say it’s fair. I could’ve done the math wrong, and I am valuing the dragon cat with demand at 1 non given its recent trade history. Second opinion could be helpful

[Foxx.ie]

can i get help with this one pls

trades/viewtrade.php?id=111292380&userid=950038&signature=yPt5Fg4wN889Aqf8J-49VQ

[Lia_]

Not good at bulk trades. Thoughts on this?

[BillyBoi]

Hey guys its me again are these fair?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=111314546&userid=1017560&signature=cNqOYCogopquJClTcfeF0w


trades/viewtrade.php?id=111309572&userid=1017560&signature=7grGuxUGllCmmkko0XwuYQ + 1000C$ in another trade

Any help would be appreciated so I can let people know if they need to add to their bids! Thank you

[eelsyrup]

Need some help with this please!
trades/viewtrade.php?id=111320107&userid=1043699&signature=qXrTYIJDJbvF_XY9vm5gqQ

[~bad_cat~]

Is this fair to me?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=111325827&userid=1027143&signature=wER6Oo020k5CBi0E7QoVww

[Horsechamp]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=111325868&userid=59454&signature=Id21QViolqtI3j-Sd79bNA I know they want me to edit this, but how would I make this fair?