The “Is this a fair trade?” Thread

[~Forgotten Dreams~]

Okay, here we go, this is actually a trade link (gosh I feel silly, thanks Kee for telling me I had the wrong one)

I'm not sure if one pet is worth one item, but I could be wrong?

anyways, thanks for help in advance!

[kee;]

@Constellation- it is unfair to you as each of your 2012 store pets are worth an early 09 rare.
If you value the zodiacs as more than a 2010 because of demand, that is up to you.

-kee

[Constellation.]

Back again! The third trade added and now I'm stuck.

WARNING: LARGE QUANTITY (of rares) IN THESE

Trade one
Trade two + This + This

They added more rares and lists. Again considering all pets will be sold for C$ (but the lists will be traded down and then sold for C$), which one is best? (:

Thanks! (: Second opinion? Added again.

[kee;]

Okay, here we go, this is actually a trade link (gosh I feel silly, thanks Kee for telling me I had the wrong one)

I'm not sure if one pet is worth one item, but I could be wrong?

anyways, thanks for help in advance!

It cruelly looks unfair to them. The Egyptian event items are worth a 2014 common/uncommon each.
I believe the other two are from 2012(?), and would be worth a 2012 common/uncommon each.

Edit: Cootie shot item is 2012, the arm band is 2011. They’re worth a common/uncommon is the corresponding year. (Though I would lean more towards uncommon for the 2011 item at least)

-kee

[Pom d'Apee]

hello c:
can anyone tell me if this trade is fair ? if not what i or they need to add tomake it fair ? '-'
thank you in advance ♥

The zodiacs are worth 09 rares, as are the 2012 storepets. Though both can fetch more with demand. The 2017 storepet is worth a late 2010 rare, I think the items make up the gap but you'd have to get a second opinion.
Actually I'd value the 2012 store pets slightly higher than the zodiacs and the 2017 slightly lower so I think it balances out.

@Constellation- it is unfair to you as each of your 2012 store pets are worth an early 09 rare.
If you value the zodiacs as more than a 2010 because of demand, that is up to you.

-kee

okay thank you for your answer ♥

[Meridiem]

Bid 1
Bid 2
Bid 3
Bid 4
Bid 5
Bid 6
Bid 7

Should I accept any of these? if so which one

[wrath of man.]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=70117249&userid=919101&signature=xTvbS6Q9k8tqERY6wzvmYg

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 4XwJvnbAsw

need help on both for an auction please

[popping star]

Are either of these fair?
1
2

[gentaro]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 9gZA73eFBw
is this trade fair?

[Meridiem]

Bid 1
Bid 2
Bid 3
Bid 4
Bid 5
Bid 6
Bid 7

Should I accept any of these? if so which one