The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[redninetails]

How does this trade look?

And this trade look?

Thank you in advance for any help! <3 ^^

2nd trade looks a little unfair to them. I thought sunback went for 4 nons? Please correct me if i'm wrong! So you would only be paying about 3. Then again Skelebun can go for one non to someone and then 2 to another, so honestly demand can play a factor. IDK though, please ask for another opinion~!

Thank you, any other thoughts? c:

[Kitkat2716]

Okay, so I've got another offer on my Cinnabon and I'm really happy with it but it's not quite a nons worth I think. So may I have some opinions? bop

Edit: o.o

[Charizard !]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... xBzR73c6eA

Ideas?

[hummxs]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=63447759&userid=839319&signature=lPQEy9uxJEF5xBzR73c6eA

Ideas?

I think they might be overpaying. Each year, store pets gain a little more value. it's very minimal though so I'd personally value the store pet at around maybe 25.5 C$. Demand-wise I personally wouldn't take it because you can easily get more for it, as it's worth a late '09 rare.

[Charizard !]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=63447759&userid=839319&signature=lPQEy9uxJEF5xBzR73c6eA

Ideas?

I think they might be overpaying. Each year, store pets gain a little more value. it's very minimal though so I'd personally value the store pet at around maybe 25.5 C$. Demand-wise I personally wouldn't take it because you can easily get more for it, as it's worth a late '09 rare.

Thank you! Second opinions?

[Rusticsmile67]

Out of curiosity, what would a full set of Lions be fair for?

(hope I can ask here)

[Guest]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=63447759&userid=839319&signature=lPQEy9uxJEF5xBzR73c6eA

Ideas?

I think they might be overpaying. Each year, store pets gain a little more value. it's very minimal though so I'd personally value the store pet at around maybe 25.5 C$. Demand-wise I personally wouldn't take it because you can easily get more for it, as it's worth a late '09 rare.

That pet is worth a 2010 rare, not a 2009! ^-^
They are overpaying by around 5C$

[hummxs]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=63447759&userid=839319&signature=lPQEy9uxJEF5xBzR73c6eA

Ideas?

I think they might be overpaying. Each year, store pets gain a little more value. it's very minimal though so I'd personally value the store pet at around maybe 25.5 C$. Demand-wise I personally wouldn't take it because you can easily get more for it, as it's worth a late '09 rare.

That pet is worth a 2010 rare, not a 2009! ^-^
They are overpaying by around 5C$

my apologies ;;
I got mixed up in the years worth. It should be worth an early '10 rare because:
-2017 store pets = late '10 rare
-2016 store pets = mid '10 rare
-2015 store pets = early '10 rare

[Charizard !]

Alright, thank you guys! ^^^

[Rusticsmile67]

is this fair? Not good with bug amounts of c$