*DISCONTINUED* Rares List Guide (1 March 2019)

[Solloby]

When will new poll start?
Really want to reach cinnabun poll

Never hopefully, the Peach poll is a pretty clear indicator that polls do not work well for valuing pets imo. Pets should be placed based on their trade values, because the Rares List aims to be a list of trade values for pets. The UR Peach cannot seem to be placed because a poll was put up and people voted for it to be valued well below what it actually traded for, and now we seem to be at an impasse. I am not sure why a poll with invalid options was put up in the first place, I was not following the conversation beforehand, but I certainly hope we don't repeat the mistake with future pets. That's my 2c at any rate.

[ElementalInsanity]

When will new poll start?
Really want to reach cinnabun poll

Never hopefully, the Peach poll is a pretty clear indicator that polls do not work well for valuing pets imo. Pets should be placed based on their trade values, because the Rares List aims to be a list of trade values for pets. The UR Peach cannot seem to be placed because a poll was put up and people voted for it to be valued well below what it actually traded for, and now we seem to be at an impasse. I am not sure why a poll with invalid options was put up in the first place, I was not following the conversation beforehand, but I certainly hope we don't repeat the mistake with future pets. That's my 2c at any rate.

I fully agree with you here Solloby.

[ratonhnhaké:ton]

When will new poll start?
Really want to reach cinnabun poll

Never hopefully, the Peach poll is a pretty clear indicator that polls do not work well for valuing pets imo. Pets should be placed based on their trade values, because the Rares List aims to be a list of trade values for pets. The UR Peach cannot seem to be placed because a poll was put up and people voted for it to be valued well below what it actually traded for, and now we seem to be at an impasse. I am not sure why a poll with invalid options was put up in the first place, I was not following the conversation beforehand, but I certainly hope we don't repeat the mistake with future pets. That's my 2c at any rate.

i'm also in complete agreement with this, and i hope everyone else agrees that it's time to actually place the peach, too.
i haven't followed the conversation 100% but it's going back to page 4 (middle of december) and it just seems ridiculous to drag it on.

it looks like dadwarf's post below has the best compilation of trades, and (to me at least) it seems like the peach should be placed above the nons since most of these seem to be valuing it as a non+. either way, it's worth is at least that of a non or higher (i personally think higher).

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... RdOu02cpfw dec 30, im assuming the peach counts as a non here.

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... _o7QpgeVyg 2 dec

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... PN7v0FvHRw 27 nov

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... xWx8CIySRQ 19 nov


http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 8G-cPbi5ww 17 okt - non worth

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... Bnm5nZPC-A 18 okt - non worth

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... zKeAvIbPsA 1 okt - non worth in c$

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... FwVhjajSLQ August - near non worth

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... a6FKd2f4aA 26 may - over a non worth

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... IaRYvavxEQ July - over a non worth

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... eclArJRp4Q March - over a non worth

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... V_adUZsx-Q feb - over non worth

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... sKthTFocJQ Jan - non worth

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 7EJ0jlFxEg ja. - over a non worth

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... f_Jli33oqw Jan - would aruge also non worth on two of them.

This is all 2017.

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... Iu5jU1ghcA 2015 after release



I think its important to remember the past 2 years. The peach has consitanly gone for more then a non and only recently had a bit of a dip. I blame that dip on false advice being spread around, re people being told its worth only 2 sorbets.

The whole reason the peach was not placed with the other ur is because upon its release people kept shouting its worth a non. It kept being spread around and around so we didnt know if it was worth a non or if that was just the worth people kept advicing for it. After 2 years, a non still seems commonly paid, over a non even.

We have two full years of looking at the peach, not just the regular one year. Lets not base its placement on a recent dip but look at the overall picture c:

can we make a final decision and move on to the zonkey/cinnabun?

[mikasi-nightwolf]

What I just Traded for the Peach.

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... yfQgzKONKQ

[myth;]

For future talks, this trade nearly happened for a skelebun.. but.. heck.. not even I could trade 7+ nons for a skelebun. ;n;
And no, they would accept no less..
Should I have accepted that?

[fιяєfℓу]

For future talks, this trade nearly happened for a skelebun.. but.. heck.. not even I could trade 7+ nons for a skelebun. ;n;
And no, they would accept no less..
Should I have accepted that?

The skelebun doesnt have a fixed value yet but its the first store pet to turn omgsr

[marmoris]

For future talks, this trade nearly happened for a skelebun.. but.. heck.. not even I could trade 7+ nons for a skelebun. ;n;
And no, they would accept no less..
Should I have accepted that?

No way. I don’t think the bun is worth 7 nons, at least not yet. I mean, eventually the bun will cost a couple limbs. But I don’t think they’re looking to place it to be worth anymore than 3-4 nons, I believe? That’s just an insane trade. The orange cerb is going for so much these days, I’m surprised they didn’t accept this, to be quite honest.

The skelebun seemed to have dipped in popularity for a while. Didn’t see them even unlocked at all. But the past month or so and I’m seeing them up in auctions and some for trade. And people expect ridiculous amounts.

[Crystal_Winterz]

Is there a reason that the royal bobtail isn't on the list but the bobtail bun is?

[Silverstar]

Is there a reason that the royal bobtail isn't on the list but the bobtail bun is?

The bunny is a lot rarer than the dog. The bunny turned very rare way before the dog did.

[myth;]

For future talks, this trade nearly happened for a skelebun.. but.. heck.. not even I could trade 7+ nons for a skelebun. ;n;
And no, they would accept no less..
Should I have accepted that?

No way. I don’t think the bun is worth 7 nons, at least not yet. I mean, eventually the bun will cost a couple limbs. But I don’t think they’re looking to place it to be worth anymore than 3-4 nons, I believe? That’s just an insane trade. The orange cerb is going for so much these days, I’m surprised they didn’t accept this, to be quite honest.

The skelebun seemed to have dipped in popularity for a while. Didn’t see them even unlocked at all. But the past month or so and I’m seeing them up in auctions and some for trade. And people expect ridiculous amounts.

People have been asking me for a UR Tiger and some for their bunnies when I've asked if they're trading them, either that or 7+ nons.. if that is not a couple of limbs already then I fear to know what is. oo' I had to trade 5 nons for my orange cerb, it wounded my fodder greatly. If you do happen to find one of these users wanting 3-4 nons for their skelebuns, please send a carrier pigeon my way. X'P




When will we be moving on to other placements? I think it's clear enough that the peach is worth a non or more, if proven otherwise it can always be moved again at a later date.