The “Is this a fair trade?” thread

[tūī]

Is this fair? The other player sent it btw ;-;

[Horror]

any of these fair?
1

2

3

i really need help, so confused!!
URGENT!!!

Adding urgent won't get you responses any quicker.
1. Unfair to them, 2016 rare = 2014 uncommon, though whether you want to trade a rare for an uncommon is up to you
2. Also unfair to them. 2016 store pet = (early) 2010 rare or 4 2010 uncommons. They're overpaying with a 2013 uncommon and the 2015+ pets
3. Wrong link

Is this fair?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=70861172&userid=887821&signature=VIXR8Uab0-8LIIH4d7nmIg

Unfair to them, a non is worth 3 sorbets, your side is hardly worth even 1 sorbet

Is this fair? The other player sent it btw ;-;

Their bun is an advent list worth 3-4 09 rares, your side isn't worth one so it's very unfair to them

[popping star]

Is this fair? The other player sent it btw ;-;

It's very unfair to the VR bunny.
Their pet is a tier one advent and it's worth 3-4 '09 rares.

[dibidibidis]

Which of these bids are better for my full original warriors set?
Can I get any more than the Blue Rose? It's really tempting ;w;
Trade 1 (blue rose)
Trade 2 (quantity)

Thanks in advance! <3

[windsorblue17]

Is this fair? The other player sent it btw ;-;

The bunny is worht 4 09' rares, so it's unfair to them.

[Valac]

Hows this? Thanks!

Edit and this?

personally I wouldn't, their side has lower demand than yours (people give a lot for the corgi set and deer set)

Thank you! Second opinion?

[nobxdy]

Fair?

I feel like this is unfair to me, but because I'm so iffy with items idk what to think. Anybody know what these items are worth? Help would be appreciated. <3

Unless there's another rares items list I'm unaware of, none of those items are enough to make the trade fair to you.

So the medieval faire items don't have any sort of value? Because I know the other ones do, even though they're not on the items list.

[buzzy]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... VXUUQ86E-A

[argyle]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=70862027&userid=787060&signature=rZtrHVGqNQOJVXUUQ86E-A

i'd say that it might be close to fair without demand, but it's definitely unfair to you because store pets have a ton of demand.

[b.umblebee]

what do y'all think of this?