The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Lemoni]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... pTGgYrRwHA

I've been told they should add a late '09 rare...can I get a second opinion? Thanks everyone!

[Hollow Knight]

Is this fair? What are the elemental cats going for?

[gooseygoo]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... NprYjvLLiQ

Is the above trade fair? It does not seem fair, but I am not entirely sure what should I edit in to make it fair. ^^''
Please PM me about it, since I will not see your reply if you respond on the thread.
Thank you.

[Quackers <3]

Is this fair? What would they need to add if it isnt? Or if not, how much is the zebra worth in trade downs? Please be specific! http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 6Gunsf6peA

Someone please?

Please correct me if I am wrong, but your Zebra is above the gap on the mainlist. They do have horrible demand, but you can still get at least a non out of them

Their side is only worth a low Mainlist.

Approx 4-5 Mid Advents worth in Rares.
Red Rose
3 Tier 1 Advents
2 Tier 5 Advents
1 Tier 4 Advent

I would value their side between a Skeleton PPS and UR Purple horse on the mainlist.

I would not value their side to a skeleton PPS, for the skeleton pps goes from 1-3 nons by its demand.
Their side values at the Red-X PPS to the UR Purple Horse (maybe!)

If you read The Main List correctly you will see that the Skeleton PPS is below the UR purple horse. The Skeleton PPS is no where near the value of 1-3 nons, please do not give false advice.

[Elwynie]

Which is fair/more fair? Thanks!

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... EFjPC0KolA

Or

(I don't have a trade but I can say the pets)

UR Cat
line tribal
blue flower 7th tier
purple sleipnir
Vixen dog
Blood-winged dog
Some items

For my Moonswirl? Thanks!!!!

I think its fair(:
The moonswirl is valued at 4 nons
the UR cat is worth 2 nons and 2 sorbets
The cinnabon is valued at 1-1.5 nons(:
I feel the store pets and excess VR's make up the gap^^

[Classification]

Is this fair? What would they need to add if it isnt? Or if not, how much is the zebra worth in trade downs? Please be specific! http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 6Gunsf6peA

Someone please?

Please correct me if I am wrong, but your Zebra is above the gap on the mainlist. They do have horrible demand, but you can still get at least a non out of them

Their side is only worth a low Mainlist.

Approx 4-5 Mid Advents worth in Rares.
Red Rose
3 Tier 1 Advents
2 Tier 5 Advents
1 Tier 4 Advent

I would value their side between a Skeleton PPS and UR Purple horse on the mainlist.

What if they added a sunjewel? Would that be over or under?

[Elwynie]

If you read The Main List correctly you will see that the Skeleton PPS is below the UR purple horse. The Skeleton PPS is no where near the value of 1-3 nons, please do not give false advice.

Oh crap LOL
I was thinking of the Skeleton bun
My bad my bad~
Im not giving out false advice.

[ruel]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... BG7ED5QTLQ

Is this fair? My dog is from 08 by the way

[Mysterious~]

Is this fair? What would they need to add if it isnt? Or if not, how much is the zebra worth in trade downs? Please be specific! http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 6Gunsf6peA

Someone please?[/quote]

Please correct me if I am wrong, but your Zebra is above the gap on the mainlist. They do have horrible demand, but you can still get at least a non out of them

Their side is only worth a low Mainlist.

Approx 4-5 Mid Advents worth in Rares.
Red Rose
3 Tier 1 Advents
2 Tier 5 Advents
1 Tier 4 Advent

I would value their side between a Skeleton PPS and UR Purple horse on the mainlist.[/quote]

What if they added a sunjewel? Would that be over or under?[/quote]

The sunjewel is worth 5 nons, the Zebra goes for 1.5. It would be way over! Even thou sunjewel are hard to trade off

[Elwynie]

Is this fair? What are the elemental cats going for?

Fair(:
The elemental cats are worth one 09 rare each, however with their demand they can go for a little more