The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[pidge gunderson]

could i get a few opinions on these trades?
1) the ur peach gets me every time
2) quantity of staff and items is great
3) im dying for the wigs and green toxic
4) the list and item quantity is jarringly great
5) this demand is amazing
thank you so much to everyone who helps.

also for ren hana:

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... WB2yLIP4IQ


is this fair? what should be added or changed? thank you

please help me out, i value the ur cinnabun for 1-1.5 nons. thank you to anyone who gives any opinions.

[עורב לבן]

Are any of these offers fair, and if so, which is the better deal, since these pets seem to be in crazy demand? Accepting one will cancel the rest (due to overlap), so I'd like to choose the best one overall. Thanks!
1. Fair?
2. Fair?
3. Fair?
4. Fair?

To everyone who keeps trading on the same pets I am asking about, please know that it is going to take me a while because I have to get opinions on the trades here first. You can trade, but if I'm asking here, it's because I don't know if it's a fair trade, so you'll have to wait along with everyone else who keeps offering on them.

[Vilhelm]

Should I add anything to my side for the cake dog? Please don't value things up using C$, if you do than my side would be over with just the pets.

[Classification]

Is this fair? What would they need to add if it isnt? Or if not, how much is the zebra worth in trade downs? Please be specific! http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 6Gunsf6peA

Someone please?

[Elwynie]

could i get a few opinions on these trades?
1) the ur peach gets me every time
2) quantity of staff and items is great
3) im dying for the wigs and green toxic
4) the list and item quantity is jarringly great
5) this demand is amazing
thank you so much to everyone who helps.

also for ren hana:

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... WB2yLIP4IQ


is this fair? what should be added or changed? thank you

please help me out, i value the ur cinnabun for 1-1.5 nons. thank you to anyone who gives any opinions.

Ren Hana's post was already answered.

1. Unfair to the cinnabon. The Cinnabon goes for 1-1.5 nons; The peach fetches 2 sorbets
2. Unfair to the cinnabon. This trade could fetch a low list pet at the least
3. Unfair to the cinnabon. However if they added a sorbet I believe it would be fair
4. Fair. The excess rares and items make up the tiny gap to the cinnabon (i personally would accept)
5. Fair. The demand of the patchwork dog makes up the gap (i personally would accept)

Is this fair? What would they need to add if it isnt? Or if not, how much is the zebra worth in trade downs? Please be specific! http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 6Gunsf6peA

Someone please?

This post has already been answered.

Is this fair? What would they need to add if it isnt? Or if not, how much is the zebra worth in trade downs? Please be specific! http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 6Gunsf6peA

Unfair to the zebra
The Plains Zebra is only worth a non (goes for underpay)
However adding a sorbet I believe would make it fair(:

[LemonadeQueen]

Which is fair/more fair? Thanks!

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... EFjPC0KolA

Or

(I don't have a trade but I can say the pets)

UR Cat
line tribal
blue flower 7th tier
purple sleipnir
Vixen dog
Blood-winged dog
Some items

For my Moonswirl? Thanks!!!!

[Quackers <3]

Is this fair? What would they need to add if it isnt? Or if not, how much is the zebra worth in trade downs? Please be specific! http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 6Gunsf6peA

Someone please?

Please correct me if I am wrong, but your Zebra is above the gap on the mainlist. They do have horrible demand, but you can still get at least a non out of them

Their side is only worth a low Mainlist.

Approx 4-5 Mid Advents worth in Rares.
Red Rose
3 Tier 1 Advents
2 Tier 5 Advents
1 Tier 4 Advent

I would value their side between a Skeleton PPS and UR Purple horse on the mainlist.

[Elwynie]

Should I add anything to my side for the cake dog? Please don't value things up using C$, if you do than my side would be over with just the pets.

I would add an advent on your side to make it fair(:

[LemonadeQueen]

Which is fair/more fair? Thanks!

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... EFjPC0KolA

Or

(I don't have a trade but I can say the pets)

UR Cat
line tribal
blue flower 7th tier
purple sleipnir
Vixen dog
Blood-winged dog
Some items

For my Moonswirl? Thanks!!!!

[Vilhelm]

Should I add anything to my side for the cake dog? Please don't value things up using C$, if you do than my side would be over with just the pets.

I would add an advent on your side to make it fair(:

Alright! Thanks so much!