The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[nafla]

Help please ><

[Charizard !]

is this fair?

and...

this?

Can't speak for the second one, but the first one is defiantly unfair to the bottom. The deer is only worth a mid/early 2010 rare?? Possibly late but I can never remember ahh

[duncundog]

I was just offered an uncommon and 70 C$ for a few of my rares. I'm bad with the worth of C$, so I need some help...

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 3r4lEbvwvA

[Stormwarden]

hi ! i was wondering if this is fair, and if not, how to make it so? i now know that a '16 store is worth a mid '10 rare, not an '09, but how much/what should i add to make it even?

[cosmic-quark]

Is this fair? Any help appreciated! <3

[nafla]

Help please ><

[ShadowStarFang]

Hia! <3

I've gotten a trade on a lovely store pet of mine and was just curious of how fair it was for me <3 Thank you bunches! <3
This Here Is The Lovely Trade
Thank you so much to everyone that helps! <3

[A.skater.Chen]

Hi! Is this fair?? If not, what would roughly need to be added?? And would you personally take it?? Thanks soo much for any help!!!!!!!!!

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... OP-ymgscgQ

[kikufuku]

Hia! <3

I've gotten a trade on a lovely store pet of mine and was just curious of how fair it was for me <3 Thank you bunches! <3
This Here Is The Lovely Trade
Thank you so much to everyone that helps! <3

Hey there! uwu

I believe it's slightly unfair to you rarity-wise, since '14 store pets are worth mid '09 rares, not late '09 rares. It also depends on how much you value the uncommon and commons - they don't have any set values but it may help if you consider the years of them! c:

Demand-wise, I believe it's quite unfair as horses don't have good demand and they're wanting a dog in return. Sure, there's an uncommon dog but it's mainly the rare horse that you should focus on. :c

I hope this could help ya! ♡

[kikufuku]

I was just offered an uncommon and 70 C$ for a few of my rares. I'm bad with the worth of C$, so I need some help...

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 3r4lEbvwvA

Oosh... ;w; that looks extremely unfair to you, both rarity and demand wise. The rereleased 2nd gen is from '08, and 08' rares are worth roughly 50 C$. The dalmatian, since it's an early 09' rare, is worth 40-45 C$. The zodiac dog though, if going by rarity, is worth 25-30 C$. If going by demand, it's the same worth as the dalmatian (they can go for 09' rares :>). The rereleased Prancer horse is from 09', and it's worth 30-35 C$.

So if we add it all up, they should be offering roughly... 145-175 C$ in total. The uncommon pet doesn't really have a set value, so it depends on what you personally value them at.

I hope this helps ya! ♡ go ahead and get another opinion though, yeah? xwx