The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[holoville]

any help would b loved :3
trades/viewtrade.php?id=111355000&userid=1106748&signature=4zDx5srWsKQ6E9VTMzwMdg

[Brienne of Tarth]

Is this fair? Any help is greatly appreciated!
trades/viewtrade.php?id=111352105&userid=72123&signature=yfMLmtsGpaErB3KUIs9G7g

CEG & BEG are worth 1.5N each

your side:
blue balloon - .5N
cheshire - .5N
blue toxic - .5N = 1.5N for the 3

red rose - .25N
red android - .5N
09 UR dog - .5N = 1.25N for the 3

brown cookie - 1MA
purple husky - 1MA
cream advent - 1MA
pink heart advent - 1MA/1.5MA
store deers - 1MA each, so 4MA
store dino - 1MA = 9MA/9.5MA for the 9

and the other 2 dogs i don't know the names of, but i can imagine they're 1MA each, though do feel free to double check. = 3MA

my math might be a tad wrong, but to me this seems to be slightly overpay on your side.
9MA would be equal to .75N, and including the extra 3MA's that pushes it to 1N.

so, your side would be 3.75N, while their side is only equal to 3.
for demand, I've seen overpay for a handful of pets on your side, though the CEG and BEG do have a decent demand, but.. depends on personal preference.

As true dates, how much are they worth? I think only the RR ones are worth 1.5 Nons.

depends on person, but according to trades from 2022 and 2023, they were considered 2N-2.5N
(2.25N, 2.5N for CEG // while a BEG was considered 2N here last year) so now you'd be under, taking that into consideration. I didn't notice they were TD until after posting my original post, apologies.

[Supreme]

Hi, would anyone be able to help me with this trade?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=111344882&userid=702384&signature=vceKnobTrYQEabD8DVvxjA

It looks close to being fair at 1non, I'm unsure about the items though, I know those scarves have crazy demand - maybe get a second opinion. If anything this may be unfair to them. Their pets are also pretty high demand!

Could I get a second opinion?

[Kate,]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=111355232&userid=830519&signature=7VyWGosGVEH0fyZ0-yIYRA
Would this be fair? I’m a little off on values.

[woo]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=111355232&userid=830519&signature=7VyWGosGVEH0fyZ0-yIYRA
Would this be fair? I’m a little off on values.

Its just a tad bit unfair on your side. Your store pet is 2 old rares (10' & 11' rares) & their store pet is worth 1 old rare. MAYBE demand wise the 2013 lion could equal to an old rare but just from a quick glimpse its a little unfair. But if you like the pets theyre offering I dont think its a bad trade.

[Ditzy Yandere]

fair trade?

trades/viewtrade.php?id=111351486&userid=106453&signature=uuHJ_OMlV1bbg0zNI7xOEQ

[Magpiejay]

still looking for help with this trade <3
https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=111343639&userid=793299&signature=bbHUj_AoMmWA_5vn3TYzCA

[clickbait]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=111343901&userid=943417&signature=X_oz4O8HEjpuVXiesOyuqw

is this a fair trade?

[Happily Wrathful]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=111343901&userid=943417&signature=X_oz4O8HEjpuVXiesOyuqw

is this a fair trade?

hiya! no their dog is worth 2 nons which is 200 old rares
your side is worth less due to the speckled rat not having good demand
at most your side is worth 150 old rares

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=111355232&userid=830519&signature=7VyWGosGVEH0fyZ0-yIYRA
Would this be fair? I’m a little off on values.

Its just a tad bit unfair on your side. Your store pet is 2 old rares (10' & 11' rares) & their store pet is worth 1 old rare. MAYBE demand wise the 2013 lion could equal to an old rare but just from a quick glimpse its a little unfair. But if you like the pets theyre offering I dont think its a bad trade.

i would like to add on that due to demand the lion is worth a old rare and can probably get that rather consistently.
if you like the lion and want to trade for them this is a fair trade though the sitting cat does have some good demand and may be able to get a better trade

[Rhýpp]

Hi! I think I could use some second opinions, the trade is finalized but I'm still curious, was this a fair trade? Warning: extreme bulk! (500+ pets for a TD UR Flamingo) Thanks in advance! <3