The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[jprspereira]

is this fair? tysm <3

Usually no, as the s'mores goes for 1.5nons and the patchwork for 2nons, but perhaps they're valuing the s'mores higher as theirs is a TD? Some people really care about URs being TDs and others don't think it matters at all. I think if you're specifically looking for a TD s'more and are wanting to pay a bit more this may be the trade you're looking for. I think other than that the times I've seen the patchwork go for 1.5nons are for really high demand stores, but that's very anecdotal and just my personal experience!

gl <3

Patchwork can get you 2.5 nons due to being a old store pet. S'mores is too recent of a UR to be boosted 0.5 nons for being TD. Their s'mores is still 1.5 nons. So, unfair.

[oceanz]

hello! I’d like advice on this trade please

I really love the Dalmatian but not sure about the others - I don’t know much about rarities/dates. Thank you!

adding on this one as well. Again thank you in advance c:

[Bria]

never mind

[Audrey_Bee]

is this fair? tysm <3

Usually no, as the s'mores goes for 1.5nons and the patchwork for 2nons, but perhaps they're valuing the s'mores higher as theirs is a TD? Some people really care about URs being TDs and others don't think it matters at all. I think if you're specifically looking for a TD s'more and are wanting to pay a bit more this may be the trade you're looking for. I think other than that the times I've seen the patchwork go for 1.5nons are for really high demand stores, but that's very anecdotal and just my personal experience!

gl <3

Patchwork can get you 2.5 nons due to being a old store pet. S'mores is too recent of a UR to be boosted 0.5 nons for being TD. Their s'mores is still 1.5 nons. So, unfair.

Hey! I just wondered where you got the information on patchwork being 2.5 nons? I've personally only ever traded 2 nons and looking at the fair trade thread have only see one trade where its been valued and actually traded for a pet valued at 2-2.5 nons which still isn't a solid 2.5 nons 🤔 no hate, just curious !

[Rhýpp]

Hi! I think I could use some second opinions, the trade is finalized but I'm still curious, was this a fair trade? Warning: extreme bulk! (500+ pets for a TD UR Flamingo) Thanks in advance! <3

[Journey]

is this fair? tysm <3

Usually no, as the s'mores goes for 1.5nons and the patchwork for 2nons, but perhaps they're valuing the s'mores higher as theirs is a TD? Some people really care about URs being TDs and others don't think it matters at all. I think if you're specifically looking for a TD s'more and are wanting to pay a bit more this may be the trade you're looking for. I think other than that the times I've seen the patchwork go for 1.5nons are for really high demand stores, but that's very anecdotal and just my personal experience!

gl <3

Patchwork can get you 2.5 nons due to being a old store pet. S'mores is too recent of a UR to be boosted 0.5 nons for being TD. Their s'mores is still 1.5 nons. So, unfair.

i disagree with this. patchwork is 2 nons solid and has been for a long time, just because its an old store pets doesnt mean it can be pushed .5 extra, and theres no trade data on this. while smores is recent, its from 2020 and its not rare to see it being traded for extra as a td

[Willow.cat]

-snip-

Usually no, as the s'mores goes for 1.5nons and the patchwork for 2nons, but perhaps they're valuing the s'mores higher as theirs is a TD? Some people really care about URs being TDs and others don't think it matters at all. I think if you're specifically looking for a TD s'more and are wanting to pay a bit more this may be the trade you're looking for. I think other than that the times I've seen the patchwork go for 1.5nons are for really high demand stores, but that's very anecdotal and just my personal experience!

gl <3

Patchwork can get you 2.5 nons due to being a old store pet. S'mores is too recent of a UR to be boosted 0.5 nons for being TD. Their s'mores is still 1.5 nons. So, unfair.

i disagree with this. patchwork is 2 nons solid and has been for a long time, just because its an old store pets doesnt mean it can be pushed .5 extra, and theres no trade data on this. while smores is recent, its from 2020 and its not rare to see it being traded for extra as a td

I agree with Stella, if you do have trade data it gets above 2 can you link it?

[BillyBoi]

Hey guys, I wanted to see the fairness/value of this trade if you could help me out! I had an estimate but the OMGSR are throwing me and it’s a bid so I’d like to update the leader if I need to thank you! ^.^

trades/viewtrade.php?id=111351095&userid=1017560&signature=MlsQ2ghrdNMYXg9-yDNLbg

[squeegi]

does this trade for a patchwork look like a fair offer ^_^?

[Happily Wrathful]

Hello! Large amounts of pets are hard for me to keep up with, please weigh in!
https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=111349061&userid=707183&signature=XPHcYnooxo68Zxpt-OX5WQ

thats some pretty crazy overpay