The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread [xat chat added]

[Mavric]

how fair is this? I want it to be an overpaythanks!!!
* new thread smell

[Pinkamena Diane Pie]

What would be a good auction bid for a Shima LongtailÉ

Offtopic: New thread smell!

It depends whether you're going for demand or fairness.

I'd ask for an early '09 rare, but a lot of people are willing to ask for more.

I`m going more for demand, I`m trying to build up my collection.

[Jenn the Psycho]

And two more things;

Was this fair?

For my COAPP'd Friend

Moonswirl for Sunjewel?
&&
Sunjewel for UR Tiger Dog?

If either is unfair, please let me know what can be added so that I may tell her.

/sniffs thread/ Yup, that's new.

No, it was unfair to you on the linked trade, the Dagon PPS is harder to find than the BMD and its higher on the list.

For your friend -
1 - I would say unfair to the sunjewel, but I do not know what to add - get another opinion.
2 - it would be a fair swap.

[asta,]

For my COAPP'd Friend

Moonswirl for Sunjewel?
&&
Sunjewel for UR Tiger Dog?

If either is unfair, please let me know what can be added so that I may tell her.

/sniffs thread/ Yup, that's new.

No, it was unfair to you on the linked trade, the Dagon PPS is harder to find than the BMD and its higher on the list.

For your friend -
1 - I would say unfair to the sunjewel, but I do not know what to add - get another opinion.
2 - it would be a fair swap.

Thank you.

Second opinions and or any knowledge on what my friend should add?

[Foi]

For my COAPP'd Friend

Moonswirl for Sunjewel?
&&
Sunjewel for UR Tiger Dog?

If either is unfair, please let me know what can be added so that I may tell her.

/sniffs thread/ Yup, that's new.

No, it was unfair to you on the linked trade, the Dagon PPS is harder to find than the BMD and its higher on the list.

For your friend -
1 - I would say unfair to the sunjewel, but I do not know what to add - get another opinion.
2 - it would be a fair swap.

Thank you.

Second opinions and or any knowledge on what my friend should add?

I reckon that your friend could add another mid-low main rares list or so to get to the sunjewel.

[asta,]

For my COAPP'd Friend

Moonswirl for Sunjewel?
&&
Sunjewel for UR Tiger Dog?

If either is unfair, please let me know what can be added so that I may tell her.

I reckon that your friend could add another mid-low main rares list or so to get to the sunjewel.

Are you thinking, maybe, a Dark Leopard to Pink Balloon area?
Counting only dogs, that is, she doesn't have any other type of main rares list pet aside from dogs...

[Joe Kerr]

Nevermind, it was answered. Thanks Hekomi!

[Foi]

For my COAPP'd Friend

Moonswirl for Sunjewel?
&&
Sunjewel for UR Tiger Dog?

If either is unfair, please let me know what can be added so that I may tell her.

I reckon that your friend could add another mid-low main rares list or so to get to the sunjewel.

Are you thinking, maybe, a Dark Leopard to Pink Balloon area?
Counting only dogs, that is, she doesn't have any other type of main rares list pet aside from dogs...

That's exactly where I'm thinking. I'd say a pet up around the pink balloon area would do it.

[Kyar]

Coontail + ??? = UR tiger.
Please and thanks.

[asta,]

Are you thinking, maybe, a Dark Leopard to Pink Balloon area?
Counting only dogs, that is, she doesn't have any other type of main rares list pet aside from dogs...

That's exactly where I'm thinking. I'd say a pet up around the pink balloon area would do it.

Thank you very much for all the help, I'll let her know. <3