The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[doliork]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=111437533&userid=791966&signature=DTkFMb03Jqcd_NXr0rITOA

bulk trades overwhelm me... could I have some help? (:

[AuroraFier]

Can I please get some help with this trade? It would be greatly appreciated!!! Trading pets for items. Would I still be overpaying?

I would be keeping the items.
trades/viewtrade.php?id=111514683&userid=1064234&signature=9dZbOaDn4D9mt-FSaoA5sg

[Wintersham]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=111530979&userid=450377&signature=BzjMTvP9K60-j7WfSMfi5A

Can I get some help on this one?

[toxxic]

Is this fair?

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=111528630&userid=83197&signature=KazbuJ2wIcz7ALvfoikWqA

[Fallendownut]

is this fair? (ignore the items)
trades/viewtrade.php?id=111528036&userid=932037&signature=osPOXb93krr5Dd6yciaWkw

[casper.]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=111531383&userid=833406&signature=Womfco7nqoV-n8_IPcm1bw

not sure on c$ values x any help is appreciated ! thanks in advance.

[Glizzyboi17]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=111531426&userid=1092304&signature=zUvURDNTZxQOGz0fwhHEpg


First time bidding on a high value pet, is this fair on my side?

[PeanutbutterBanana]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=111521194&userid=1094415&signature=_nQNsJ3MEtRGJA0pNPi5Bw

Is this fair and if not how much of a difference is there? I'm still learning about rarities and value

[musicgurl333]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=111531383&userid=833406&signature=Womfco7nqoV-n8_IPcm1bw

not sure on c$ values x any help is appreciated ! thanks in advance.

Unfair to them. 25C$ is equal to an old rare, and your pet is quite a bit more recent. There's no special demand for it that I'm aware of.

is this fair? (ignore the items)
trades/viewtrade.php?id=111528036&userid=932037&signature=osPOXb93krr5Dd6yciaWkw

Very unfair to you. The Dec. 18th pets are from old rares between '09 and '11. There are more pets on your side, plus you have a few VRs. You also have some dogs on your side, which have better demand than rats and ponies.

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=111530979&userid=450377&signature=BzjMTvP9K60-j7WfSMfi5A

Can I get some help on this one?

It depends on whether or not you use the "2:1 rule" or the "3 year rule". If you use the "2:1 rule", it's unfair to the top. Their '19 rare is worth 2 '20 rares, and your side wouldn't add up to that. Personally, I don't use that rule and I don't recommend it.

Using the "3 year rule", the '20 and '19 rares would be a fair swap. The 2 EUCs would be equal to your '21 rare and they would need one more VUC added to equal the '20 uncommon.

Overall, I think it seems like a reasonable trade. It's slightly under using the "3 year rule", but not by a lot, and it's unfair to them using the "2:1 rule", making it somewhere in the middle. I'm not sure how demand compares, but I don't think there's anything with amazing/terrible demand on either side.

[BlankRedColor]

is this fair?


trades/viewtrade.php?id=111533429&userid=182352&signature=KcOaRHUxAGBje4I8NeIJOA