The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[2kcarat_gold]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=111447445&userid=258999&signature=YnyZCxZTFwXadGOm1HrPQw

trades/viewtrade.php?id=111426642&userid=258999&signature=ueYLuP5ipQ_mwar7vPG_kQ

could someone tell me if these are fair?

[Never & Rush]

i keep getting anxious about trying to trade my older pets for newer ones please tell me if this is unfair for them! i tried to kinda calculate out how much everything would cost in C$ if either side was for C$ and high-balled the lions since i know they have good demand, but i just want to make sure it's at least fair for them ^^;

if you use the 2:1 year for dates then they are underpaying!

thank you! i appreciate you taking time to answer! :)

i don’t use the 2:1 rule, especially for rare pets with this big of a gap cause it just wouldn’t make sense imo, so another opinion using a different method would be appreciated as well <3

[AuroraFier]

I cancelled this because I feel like it was unfair for my dog. Only felt like it was unfair because they were asking for newer rares on top of the dog. Was I wrong? Just wanted to get a second opinion.

trades/viewtrade.php?id=111448186&userid=1064234&signature=TCG17PTczEcKZ7vvTp03_g

They sent in a new offer. I'd like help before making a decision.

trades/viewtrade.php?id=111448217&userid=1064234&signature=NPc2_-kbQsMOcGXYhjGcrw

[birdiesong]

I cancelled this because I feel like it was unfair for my dog. Only felt like it was unfair because they were asking for newer rares on top of the dog. Was I wrong? Just wanted to get a second opinion.

trades/viewtrade.php?id=111448186&userid=1064234&signature=TCG17PTczEcKZ7vvTp03_g

They sent in a new offer. I'd like help before making a decision.

trades/viewtrade.php?id=111448217&userid=1064234&signature=NPc2_-kbQsMOcGXYhjGcrw

your zombie pps is worth 4-5 old rares (since it’s a true date and pps dog i’d valued it at 5). the first offer is unfair because of the extra add ons, if it had just been for the pps it would’ve been fair.

the second offer is fair as they’re offfering 5 old rares.

[AuroraFier]

I cancelled this because I feel like it was unfair for my dog. Only felt like it was unfair because they were asking for newer rares on top of the dog. Was I wrong? Just wanted to get a second opinion.

trades/viewtrade.php?id=111448186&userid=1064234&signature=TCG17PTczEcKZ7vvTp03_g

They sent in a new offer. I'd like help before making a decision.

trades/viewtrade.php?id=111448217&userid=1064234&signature=NPc2_-kbQsMOcGXYhjGcrw

your zombie pps is worth 4-5 old rares (since it’s a true date and pps dog i’d valued it at 5). the first offer is unfair because of the extra add ons, if it had just been for the pps it would’ve been fair.

the second offer is fair as they’re offfering 5 old rares.

Thank you so much for the help!! That's what I was thinking, but wanted to make sure. ^-^ I appreciate the help!

[TrashCanCat]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=111446205

Thoughts on this? I'm not too sure.

wrong link <3 try the one at the very bottom of the trade!

trades/viewtrade.php?id=111446205&userid=969010&signature=taYvHpylv_HmNblIpqxvwA
Thank you! Been so long since I've posted here :,3

[Mysticbxbblez]

Any thoughts on this?


trades/viewtrade.php?id=111429515&userid=1040543&signature=YrWJXwlKaZt0pTGnPyu57Q

[musicgurl333]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=111446205

Thoughts on this? I'm not too sure.

wrong link <3 try the one at the very bottom of the trade!

trades/viewtrade.php?id=111446205&userid=969010&signature=taYvHpylv_HmNblIpqxvwA
Thank you! Been so long since I've posted here :,3

Unfair to them any way you look at it. They’re offering 2 ERs to your 1.5, and their spider is much older. There’s no special demand for any of the pets.

[CaptainAltenor]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=111452045&userid=998167&signature=ScoWhVow1EImBLfsVtd8fQ

I'm not sure how to go about this. Not too many valuable pets, however, it is a decently sized trade and I still want to ensure that it's fair.

[musicgurl333]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=111452045&userid=998167&signature=ScoWhVow1EImBLfsVtd8fQ

I'm not sure how to go about this. Not too many valuable pets, however, it is a decently sized trade and I still want to ensure that it's fair.

Extremely unfair to you, unless the opossum has some crazy demand that I don’t know about. Just the ‘21 and ‘23 EUC pets on your side would be plenty. (That’s actually still overpay if you use the “2:1 rule”, but I personally don’t.)