[Muffin_Wolf]

Did I do an ok job on these guys? Please be nice, but don't be afraid to critique! Thanks everyone!

[KayTheProblemPup]

Yes these are awesome and well made! But my one critique is that the dots on the two dogs are too perfect, fur doesn't make a perfect circle so make if a little more loose (if you get what that means lol) Otherwise these are good.

[Muffin_Wolf]

Thank you! I will try and use your info the next time!

[saltcow]

i really like the first one!

the rainbow on on the bottom is just a little bit blocky and eh.

i would suggest using the blend tool, air brush, or pastel colors look really nice!

[Muffin_Wolf]

Thank you! I'll try that the next time!

[sockwearer]

Personally, the fourth is the best. I would suggest to make the paw markings on the third less level, maybe make one have a tiny bit higher up white than the others. Also, agreeing with the other suggestions that have been made so far.

[CrazyB]

Did I do an ok job on these guys? Please be nice, but don't be afraid to critique! Thanks everyone!

i redid your heres some improvements for you ...you can do what ever you want with them except id like to keep the 4th one
viewtopic.php?f=32&t=3677573

[Muffin_Wolf]

Thank you all for the suggestions! :3

[Pixelated_Prophecies]

My only advice is for the rainbow one. I would suggest using only one to three colors and using shades or tints of those colors (example: character with blue, light blue, dark blue, orange, light orange). Other than that, these designs look good!