Rate the Warrior Name! { v3 ;; read rules. }

[frankie (dup)]

Badgerface- 9/10- Not sure about the suffix, but I LOVE the prefix and the description.

Skyfall- 10/10

My turn!

Poppyleaf- A torishell she-cat with green eyes, a medicine cat, she is an ace at intercepting signs from StarClan- but is a HUGE worrywart.

Whispermoon- A white she-cat with grey specks and blue eyes- she has not spoken since she watched her leader purposley drown her brother.

Rainstorm- A stubborn, silver tom with blue eyes and a shredded ear, he has a marking on his chest in the shape of a white raindrop.

[joji]

poppyleaf- 10/10
whispermoon- 7.5/10
rainstorm- 5/10

--

Swanfur- white tom with yellow eyes

cherrynose- tortoiseshell tabby queen with a red nose and tongue.

smallpoppy- small tan tabby tom medicine cat

[frankie (dup)]

Swanfur- 8/10 Suffix feels too common, and it brings to mind a she-cat

Cherrynose- 9/10 Brings to mind a tom

Smalloppy- 9/10 (Look up)

Oneflight- As an apprentice, this orange furred green-eyed cat was carried off by an eagle, he returned with the eagle dead in his mouth- when his brother asked him about the eagle, Onepaw said- 'I'm not doing it again'

Wildsong- A white she-cat with blue eyes, her meow is very strange.

Sweetsplash- A medicine cat, this white furred, yellow eyed she-cat has the strange ability to apply herbs with no pain.

[Jaskiest]

i am a traditional namer & rater.

oneflight - 5/10 - one- doesn't tell you much about the cat. a prefix is meant to help you tell which cat is which: ie you'd know someone with a fire- prefix would have a ginger/red pelt. i feel like -flight being a reference to his being taken by an eagle isn't a kind thing to do as it was probably a traumatic experience for any cat. if they were able to kill an eagle single-handedly as just an apprentice, -claw to represent their fighting skills might be better c:
wildsong - 5/10 - again, wild- as a prefix doesn't help identify the cat - all warriors are wild. additionally, a white cat with blue eyes is highly likely to have hearing problems. something like cloud- would work much better as a prefix. i feel like her suffix could be seen as mocking her for having a strange meow? it doesn't really say anything positive about her. if she has no particular skills then -pelt or -fur or -face if she is very pretty would work much better.
sweetsplash - 2/10 - nothing about this name tells you about the cat. cats can't taste sweetness so the prefix doesn't make sense, and also you're not going to be able to pick someone out because they 'look sweet' in the clan - a colour implying prefix is much more effective such as daisy-. -splash isn't traditional and the only way i've seen it used is to note swimming ability and seeing as this isn't mentioned i'd guess she doesn't have this. if she has special healing powers, then -leaf would probably be best as it marks her as an exceptional medicine cat.

--

beetlecloud - a small black tom who has no notable skills but is very patient and laid-back.
tiptail - a small ginger-and-white molly who loves climbing and excels at it, being lithe and agile. the orange tip is an orange an white of butterfly found in the uk.
tigerfoot - a very fast ginger tabby molly.

[frankie (dup)]

Maybe crazy Bluestar named the first two lol. And I chose 'One' because he only killed an eagle once. I chose 'Wild' because her meow is starnge.

I chose 'Sweetsplash' because 1. The herbs she applies are done so with no pain, which is SWEET lol, and splash because polutices are liqudy and usually sting.

Beetlecloud- 10/10, name fits perfectly with the description

Tiptail- 9/10, not a fan of the prefix, but the name fits with the description.

Tigerfoot- 9/10, yes, tigers are fast, but unless he has stripes, Cheetah might work better :3

My names (Thanks to poison prince for urging me to go into more detail of WHY they have their names!)
Wolfthorn- A grey, very impulsive tom with amber eyes and looks a little dog like. I chose 'Wolf' for his appearance and colour, and 'Thorn' because they're sharp and you don't know when they'll strike. (Permission to use)

Goldfoot- A kind, tan tom with green eyes and paws a slightly different shade, more of a golden colour. I chose 'Gold' actually because of his kindness, and 'Foot' because his leader was going to name him GoldHEART but then saw his paws and changed her mind.

Pebbledust- A gray tom with yellow eyes. I chose 'Pebble' because of his colour. And 'Dust' becuase, as an apprentice, he stopped two kits from climbing down a ravine to 'explore' by showing them what would happen if they fell- he knocked a pebble over the edge, turning it to dust.

[Keriae]

Tigerfoot was described as a tabby molly. Tabbies have stripes, and the prefix Tiger- implies stripes.

Wolfthorn - 5/10 - Wolves come in many different colours, making the prefix unreliable. To add onto this, wolves are a top predator and cats living in the same environment are highly likely to be hunted. -thorn has no meaning in a traditional sense. If he;s unpredictable, -storm would suit him.
Goldfoot - 5/10 - Gold- should be Golden-, as he is golden in colour, not gold. A mother is not going to know her kitten will be kind and give him the name Goldkit. If he has the personality for the -heart suffix, that should come first. The -foot suffix is a skill suffix and used for fast cats.
Pebbledust - 5/10 - Pebble- suits him fine, especially if he's small. A pebble wouldn't turn to dust from being knocked over the edge; that's not how physics works. It'd crack. If he has no skills or a nameable personality, -fur or -pelt fit fine.

Buntingface - a tabby and white tom, noted to be very handsome. He is named after the reed bunting.
Valerianclaw - a white molly, highly skilled in fighting.
Falconcloud - a blue grey tabby with minimal whitespotting. He's noted to have a calm aura and often resolves fights.

[frankie (dup)]

Whoop, I know nothing about physics, and I guess I must have skipped over the tabby part.... XD I think the common color for wolves is grey, but they could be brown, or white, and I REALLY don't wanna spend a day typing this post...
Also, I think I might have seen a cat with the suffix 'Wolf' but I've read almost all of them... so... yeah....

Buntingface 8/10- I've never seen the word 'Bunting' used, so I don't know if cats know what that is. I don't know what 'Face' has to do with him :3 But I do like the name.

Valerianclaw- 9/10 Look up, first part. 'Claw' makes sense though.

Falconcloud- 10/10, Nothing against this lovely name and fitting description.



Mudeye- Just one this time around, his mother originally names him for his brown pelt, but Mudeye was a fitting warrior name for his strange appearance of one brown and one blue eye.

[Keriae]

Bunting-
-face
Valerian-

Mudeye - 7/10 - prefix fits fine, suffix is okay but not traditional (which is the naming system I rate by c:).

Redflower - dark ginger molly, very protective and motherly, but raises her kits in what some might consider a harsh way.
Shrewfur - small brown tabby male, with no notable skills.
Ivynose - longhaired black male, with notable tracking skills.

[lady chocobo]

Redflower - 10/10
Shrewfur - 10/10
Ivynose - 10/10


Tinynose
Silverface
Boragepelt
Bramblecloud

[Jaskiest]

i am a traditional namer and rater.

--


tinynose - 10/10 a very small cat who excells at tracking due to their great sense of smell.
silverface - a very pretty silver tabby.
boragepelt - 10/10 a blue/grey cat with no notable skills.
bramblecloud - 10/10 a brown tabby who has no notable skills but a patient personality.

--

beetlecloud - a small black tom who has no notable skills but is very patient and laid-back. he has his eye on tiptail, thinking her beautiful and confident like he wishes to be, but is far too shy to say anything - especially when she terrifies him with her antics!
tiptail - a small ginger-and-white molly who loves climbing and excels at it, being lithe and agile. the orange tip is an orange an white of butterfly found in the uk. she is very confident in her abilities. having only just become a warrior she is even more arrogant than usual, loving to irritate the other warriors by climbing up trees and jumping down infront of them with a yowl.
tigerfoot - a very fast ginger tabby molly. she is terrified of the nursery because she can't think of anything worse than tiny creatures with claws and teeth where she has to be 'patient' as they're 'only playing' when they pounce on her tail, and she 'must not scare them off by running'.