Rate The Character Above You V.7 (New rule Pg 224)

[shadowphoenixfox]

6/10
I'm not really into anthro characters so sorry the rating is probably a little too harsh. First off I love the backstory I think the doctor for the wrong reasons is a pretty neat and funny concept. However I find the overall design to be pretty plain and generic the most notable thing about him is his mane but I just feel like I've seen similar stuff before. I would also say the browns and golds clash a bit with the mane I would suggest for going with silver for the jewellery and just generally sticking to cooler or more neutral palette outside the mane. Also, might be nitpicking here but I'm little confused as to why he's wearing a cross despite being a demon.

This new character?

Art and design by me

I just made her so I'm wide open for critique. My vague idea of her so far is she was created as a guardian of a tundra somewhere and has some ice powers. Always looking for the best spot to take a nap

[PARK]

i stared at her for a solid 5 minutes trying to find anything to critique but she's perfect. i love her big cat-like body, dragon snout and whiskers, her horns, the mix of realism in the markings and the mythological aspect of everything else... she's just so beautiful. 10/10 ;v;

⸺⸺⸺⸺⸺⸺⸺⸺⸺⸺⸺⸺⸺


base from the online game dergun town, design and color by me.
ref, ref w/o sunglasses, ref w/o hair so you can see his horn and ears.

this is hugh/hughe! i'd love to get actual art of him but for now this is all i have ;; don't have much on
him yet. he's gay, loves mandarin oranges and probably never stops eating them, and never takes off
his shades. in anthro form he's dressed in like... "greaser" style. and he hides his horn with his hair but
he can cast spells with it. idk what kinda spells, ideas would be cool!

my inspo for him was colorful 80s toys, like popples, care bears, and rainbow brite! and i just think it's
fun to have a cute lookin' character that's actually a cool dude. here's his th page.

[sheena]

7/10 || while i do see what you were going for and i certainly like the ideas behind it, i do feel this character is a little big lacking. when i think 80s toys or rainbow brite, i would imagine something far more saturated and bright, and this character is a little 'washed out' if you follow me. i do think there's tons of good potential here, i really like the colour placement and the 'feathery' bits coming off him. the shades and the idea of a greaser hairstyle are also super cool! my only beef if he doesn't feel saturated enough to me, but that's mostly my own opinion! if you like him the way he is, there is never a need to change.

tyr? art and redesign by me -- original design by honrin. she's a fallen angel who fell to the sin of pride. her full story needs a little more work, as i'm currently working on getting it sorted. her toyhouse page is here and has both her old design, and an alternate with wings.

[Monomares]

9//10 That character is gorgeous. I have a soft spot for grayscale so the colours are very pleasing to look and the overall layout of the markings is incredible. The blindfold/cloth is suoer neat and adds a lot to the design, along with the horns. Total dream character here I'd die for her. The fallen angel storyline is very intriuging as well. The only reason it isn't 10//10 is because despite what I said about grayscale, I love when there's a little bit of colour, just so everything pops. But total love from me.

(Apologies if the image is very big)

How about South? (Art and Design by Me)
Toyhou.se (For personality and likes/dislikes)
South is a main character from my OC universe, Directional. He is a Police Officer with the local PD. He's also 6'2-ish tall from paws to eartips.
After his parents gave him up at birth, he had a hard life with foster homes; after he moved to a small village with his adoptive brother, he had no idea he was living next to his real parents who procceded to dump his newborn brother on him. After about 3 years, their father attacks them, killing his brother and seriously wounding him. He meets up with a wolf from the nearby Tribe, Feather, and they fall in love. She moves in with him and they have 3 kids within the next 5 years. One of their sons is attacked by South's father and is in a coma for 3 months, scarred. Feather helps him deal with his anxiety and depression from everything he's been through.

That's, uh, as short as I could get his story without leaving important details out ^^;

[Cruxich]

5/10 Apologies, but they're kind of a bit too simple for my personal tastes. They just look like a common pure grey canine with a scar and a hoodie(?) to make them stand out at least a bit. The eyes are nice though, being black and white instead of being normal. Story-wise, I love it. Backstories with a tragic event are kind of a low-key interest for me, but I do feel really bad for him.
Sorry this isn't much, but there's not a lot else to rate. If you love your character though, I'm glad. After all, it's just an opinion.

Sugar? By GhostDice

Sugar is a canine with a big passion for colorful things, especially stickers that she enjoys decorating her hair and tail with. She's very open and hyperactive, but she's also kinda scatterbrained and doesn't show the most intelligence at times. The pink whale plush Sugar carries around is a major comfort item she had ever since she was a pup, so is very clingy and protective of it. She's well known for freaking out whenever it's not around. The bandanna around her neck is merely an accessory and serves no purpose other then looks, same with the bracelets on her right front leg.
(Also yes, she's wearing lipstick)

[sheena]

7/10 || you know, i'm actually super torn on this character and was initially inclined to give her a lower rating just based on personal preference, but i don't think she deserves it. while the colour choices are a little too saturated for me, they do still match together very nicely, and i actually really like the simplicity of the markings and the little baubles in her hair/tail. the whale is also super cute, i love that. my only real nitpick is i feel like the colour of the bandanna clashes a little bit with the rest of the design, i would have been inclined to make it match with other accessories (though that's my own opinion). overall, while not my cup of tea, i think this character has a relatively solid design.

this character? she's unnamed as of right now, so name recommendations would be neat. she doesn't have much of a backstory or role yet, other than that i'm leaning towards her being a chaotic type, so please rate on design alone. original design by riftskeen, revamp and art below by me.

[EmptyAccount238t]

8/10
I'm not a big fan of pinks and purples, but she is adorable! She has a sort of witchy vibe, and I don't see many sabre characters! The underside of her cloak seems a bit cluttered though, and would be hard to replicate unless you made a texture file for it, so I'd recommend doing that! Other than that, lovely design!

Cuddle Buppy? (art and design by me)


He is just... a dog-ified version of a character from a musical! I don't have much to say about him!

[clemen]

9/10
I’m usually not a fan of red colors but this design
really works well. I like the vibes it gives off and
it would definitely a character I would buy and
right about. The red works very well with the
overall design. I like the items and the eyes stood
out to me, and don’t forget that cute expression?!
The only thing I would change is maybe some of the
accessorie colors, but that’s an option. But other
than that I absolutely love this character!

How about my boy dodo?
He studies extinct animals and often can be found eating food.
don’t have much of him yet because I bought him yesterday ^^

[leverage]

7 out of 10!
There are aspects of this design that I really like and other aspects that I am less fond of. My absolute favorite part of the design is definitely the feather details-- the wings and tail are fabulous! The gradient of cool colors with white tipping are gorgeous, especially with the grey/brown base of the design and the splotchy markings. That part of the design is wonderful and truly makes a really awesome design! The part of the design I don't like so much are the orangey-cream markings on the nose, belly, and paws. The cream color is too saturated for my taste and clash with the base coat, and the orange conflicts with the cool markings of the blues, purples, and greens of the design. It sort of feels as though there are two concepts going on in this design. I think even just lessening the saturation of the orange would make the design more my taste. That being said, the design is overall very cute! I especially love the concept you have for him in studying extinct species. He may not entirely be my taste in characters but there are aspects of his design that are absolutely wonderful, and I'm really excited to see him around!



Set, designed by sighss and art by onlyhalfpigeon
Set is a victim of an ancient curse that caused the downfall of her ancestors. The curse befell descendants of a long-lost tribe when they accidentally entered the tribe's former lands, and caused them to be afflicted with a barrier from leaving the desolate canyon and periodically drives them to fits of madness. Set had the misfortune to wander onto this land and has been unable to leave since. Instead, she must watch her body occaisionally go into fits of rage, attacking anyone in sight. The canyon where she lives, far at the edge of the kingdom, is frequented only by merchants and travelers. Set is forced to rob them for food in order to stay alive. She is a timid and nonconfrontational soul who hates who she has been forced to become. She is terrified of her own curse and abilities, moving with her head low and eyes downcast, doing what she needs to in order to survive and wishing she could break the curse, or for companionship in this fate.

[Stonefly]

10/10 - Im going to start with, I love this girl?
I love characters with natural designs that aren't overly complicated and this kid fits it perfectly. Plus they kinda have the same colours as my favourite wolf from work so that's a bonus. But the colours and design work really well together and I like the how she gets twigs ands leaves stuck in her coat, such a lovely concept for a character like this.
The story that goes with her is interesting, and unfortunate for her that shes stuck where she is. But I think it just works well with the design itself, sandy wolf being forces to live and rob within a canyon? I support it lol.
But all together, I love everything about this girl and would love to see more about her world and what not if there is!



My boy Marcus! Design by me art by ghost beast.art

He’s a blind boy, born without eyes. His vision is pretty much equal to what daredevil from marvel has. So he’s still able to function in life.
The wraps are optional on both canine and human form.

He’s an angry boy, unable to form any kind of relationship with anyone. Cold and cut off with the world in general.