⊰ discussion for the 5 clans ⊱

[amethyst14]

I don't know about personal star stones or what you call it, as in the books they do travel to it. To me it's like that place is sacred and no one can mess with it no matter what clan or outsider you are from. I like the idea of an old leader getting away with murder, I'm sure he will be caught. But what clan is he she going to be from? And Birchclan is no where near twolegs

[eltonn]

my idea was this:

each bit of territory has a meteor crash site on it, with a small pool of water surrounding the meteor. So, 5 in total. They are all in a defining part of the clan's territory, for example, Stoneclan's would be on a mountain ridge near the top, because mountains are the most prominent thing in their territory.

Also, a question:
If a cat crosses the borders, should they go to that clans disscussion? For example: Eveningleaf crossing Birchclan's border to gather a few herbs. Should she stay in the Stoneclan topic or post in the Birchclan one? x3

[amethyst14]

Post in Birchclan thread so that way we know and maybe put somewhere the clan they are from?

[eltonn]

mk that makes sense, i was just asking hypotheticly x3

[magnapinna]

Great idea, For Venomclans it would be near a river

[storm coming.]

actually i'm not sure i'm liking the idea of the starclan place going missing... just because there is already a murderer and that seems a bit... much? i'm not sure if it's just me. and meteors hardly ever hit earth because the atmosphere protects us so that would be unrealistic.

so who wants to be next to willowclan?

[amethyst14]

I think from what I got willowclan is next to Venomclan. Stoneclan is in a mountain area. While cloverclan and bicycling seem to be further in the forest.

If there are separate mentor places and they make like a little pool with the stone in the middle, wouldn't they be to big to move?

[eltonn]

actually i'm not sure i'm liking the idea of the starclan place going missing... just because there is already a murderer and that seems a bit... much? i'm not sure if it's just me. and meteors hardly ever hit earth because the atmosphere protects us so that would be unrealistic.

I agree with the first part, the starclan place should stay where they are, i dont think someone would be able to steal them x3
on the unrealistic thing, think about it: Moonstone is pretty unrealistic. The chances of the hole in the ceiling in the exact perfect spot to direct the light into the cave, and then only onto the stone is next to impossible. Moonpool is almost as strange. How do pawprints appear in stone? Why does the water glow? its also a bit too perfect x3

what if the 5 moonrocks or whatever they are all split from one meteor that fell apart as it entered the atmosphere? and that's why there are 5 clans? also maybe the area for gathering could be a huge dead tree, almost like a spire, that had petrified over time ouo?

my ideas are crazy :L .....

[storm coming.]

i don't really like the idea of it being surrounded by a pool of water. a meteor hitting earth is one thing, but water magically surrounding it is another. x3 we could just have a normal starclan place like something called the shimmering waters, and there could be something to represent the five clans there instead?

for the gathering place: it could be called the great oak cx

[eltonn]

alright x3 i like the idea of it being some kind of water, though hmm....

what if at every moonwhatever there were 5 claw marks on it somewhere placed by the original 5 leaders to show that the clans must always be together or something?

EDIT; o3o i forgot to mention...Stoneclan has been having a dog problem.. not a super terrible one, dogs killed their last leader, and have been sighted a few times in the territory.. but what if the cats blamed the deaths on the dogs, not suspecting exiled cats?