He flicks a paw dismissively at the words FlurryStar speaks, "you'll choose, you'll see." Is replied softly, then he continues to listen. Soon though, anger is in his heart, it's not a path he CHOSE, it's one he had no choice in. "Cowards." Is snarled bitterly, before his next words are thwarted by the clawless she-cat.
"I... I've s-seen it." Is admitted to FlurryStar. "W-when he r-rescued me, f-from the t-twolegs, " she can feel SparrowClaws' eyes on her, see as he shakes his head, but she presses forward resolutely. "A m-mm-monster b-bit him, I saw and t-then -"
SparrowClaw swallows, "and he knows things, before they happen. Even things about others that he shouldn't. Like that there would be a flood in RiverClan," a pause, "and how the kits would be washed away... I was one of those kits. He saved my life." The giant frowns to himself, "if none of you will do as he says I will."
Fallens' whiskers twitch, "its fine, SparrowClaw, " is said at last, "they don't want to know the truth. "
"Now just a moment!" The ex deputy of ShadowClan calls out, "you chose for your children and you chose for yourselves to follow myself and RyePool out of ShadowClan. I am following FlurryStar and the will of StarClan. Some of you aren't old enough to catch prey BY YOURSELVES, and as your former deputy I am telling you that FallenRains is trustworthy, he's saved more lives than he would admit to, he's as old as the clans themselves, as old as StarClan... " a pause where yellow eyes turn on the cats one by one, "your elders would have mentioned ONE name of his, at least, you know him. He's not a rouge. I trust FallenRains. "
MossBlossom wants to be brave, wants to speak without fear, but... she can't. FrogLeap took all that from her. "FlurryStar," and for once her tongue doesn't stutter or stammer, "I know F-fallenRains. If you t-trusted mme b-before, t-trust me n-now. He ISNT a r-rouge. He's s-s-sent by SstarClan, he d-doesnt lie. I saw him d-d-die, a-ah-and come b-back." She swallows, "he k-knows th-things. S-starClan a-al-already h-have made a d-decision, b-but w-we n-need him. Wh-we will."
SparrowClaw has begun to pace, "you say you need a sign, " is begun, "try the snow in ShadowClan territory, remember? And nothing grew! nothing... it was a sign, and when RyePool passed it a half moon ago because DarkStar was being a foxheart to everyone, when she stopped at the snow and smiled there was Lilly of the Valley. The flower that symbolizes change, new beginnings, and remembrance for those we’ve lost. Haven't we lost? Isn't this a change?" Burning gold eyes turn on FlamePelt. "Wasn't the Lilly discussed at length by our leader and medicine cat?"
"It is, was.." says the father of the three apprentices; "DaisyFlower and I decided to bring our kits with SparrowClaw and RyePool because of DarkStar.. he... wasn't himself, as any cat from ShadowClan can attest to. We agreed to follow SparrowClaw to the new place. " He takes a breath, "we ShadowClan cats know that ____ our medicine cat wasn't really chosen by StarClan and that DarkStar killed his own mate who was chosen to lead just after her kits turned eight moons old. We know this. We also know that ShadowClan was punished for their hubris."
EmberPaw swallows and shakily speaks, "i... I had a sign," is said by the third and mostly unnoticeable sibling, their quiet voice breaking through the arguement.