Snow! wrote:Is there possibley a dog food that could make your dog not gain any weight? None of the dog food brands that you named were it. Only asking since, my dog, Buddy, is really thin. We give plenty of food to eat each day. o far we have had him for about 9 months. He was about 5 months when got him, he is a little over 1 year now, but he never gains anything at all. He is still thin, bout the same as when we got him. Could it possibly be the food. Im not sure what the brand is but it has the word 'soup' in it. Thank yoi
As stated before, "Chicken Soup for the dog lovers soul" has had a recall so you may want to check it out.

How much does he weight?
What breed is he?
How is he thin?
How much excersize does he get a day?
How many cups do you feed a day? Not scoops, but 8oz cups.. Unless your on metric then it'd be the equivalent, but pretty sure its strictly a US brand. ;D
Pictures from the side and above?
People now-a-days see a dog with a bit of rib and assume its "to skinny". I like my dog with some rib on her and think its the perfect weight. Not fully visible, but when she moves or twists I like her rib becoming very slightly visible. I also like her having a nice trim waist.

You can see the faintest rib on her. Then from above that trim waist:
Boy friends doberman:
Boy friends mother elderly lab mix:
All these dogs look really good with their weight. =) These dogs are also all different ages and breeds. Rottie that's 6, Dobbie thats 2ish and just out of puppy years, and lab mix thats roughly 10.
Besides, puppies go through this reallllyy lanky 'teenager' faze anyways where they tend to be all leg and stringy muscle. He should fill out as he gets older!
GrumpyCinnamonster wrote:Ordered Earthborn for small dogs. I'm going to give it a try, and if it works out, then I might eventually convert them onto the primitive Earthborn. Assuming they even like Earthborn, and assuming I can convert them onto the primitive version in the future, since the primitive one is mostly protein, will I need to be supplementing their diet more than what I already do? When they aren't eating kibble(due to the recall they aren't eating any kibble at the moment) I give them boiled chicken, a small amount of steamed rice, raw spinach or greens, grated carrots or yams, grated zucchini, and grated summer or acorn squash. For fruit, it's normally black berries or blue berries, but we do have a small raspberry bush(it grew into our yard from the neighbors. We are never sure if it is going to come back each year) that gets some fruit during the year, and the dogs love to pick the berries off. Sometimes I'll share a golden delicious apple or d'anjou pear with them. Apples and pears are occasional treats(as I said, normally when I'm having one I just share), because I worry they would give my dogs diarrhea. Prince sometimes get's cottage cheese or low-fat plain yoghurt, because his occasional extreme separation/night anxiety upsets his stomach. The vet said it would help him. Now, I don't know if it really does, but I rarely give it to him, since adding steamed rice to their homemade meals seemed to work better than the cottage cheese/yoghurt.
Don't be afraid of protein! Dog are carnivorous with inclination to being opportunistic omnivores, but still carnivores through and through. Veg, fruit, and especially grain really have no place in a canines diet. While fruits and veg do offer additional vit's and min's its important that they are no where near a significant part of the diet. Besides, many fruits and veggies are double sided, especially things like broccoli or spinach. Broccoli in large amounts can surpress the thyroid gland on a dog and spinach, along with a lot of other veg and dark leafy greens contains oxalates which are toxic to a dogs kidneys if fed in excess. Fruits contain sugar which totally stresses out a dogs pancreas. Besides, veg mater has to be altered, the cellulose wall has to be broken down first by grinding or cooking.
Protein is actually the building blocks to a healthy coat and a healthier dog. Protein sheds excess fat while building up strong lean muscle. You might find this to be an interesting read if nothing else:
http://rawfed.com/myths/cookedfood.htmlAllssoo you may have heard the myth "Dogs fed high protein diets will have kidney issues" his is false. They were testing on rats which are omnivores leaning towards herbivorous.
Cool blog on dog food:
http://rufflyspeaking.net/blog/choosing ... ee-kibble/