~Warrior Cats Fan Club V.5~

[Esther~]

I've always loved Brightheart. She was such an amazing character

I saw somewhere that the hunters want Cinderheart to be leader. Thats better then the next in line X3

[catbookdo]

Who's idea was it to put Brightflower and Lilywhisker in the dark forest? (I'm guessing it's Su Suann's?) I only found this out about two weeks ago and it's really bothering me that they just put (mostly) innocent cats in the dark forest for what reason? They got sad their leg broke, and they got sad their kits got murdered? Sheesh the dark forest has really upped their standards since then.

[Esther~]

Spoilers Below

Mapleshade didn't deserve the dark forest either. The leader and his sister were more upset with her because she lied about their brother being the father. If it were any other warrior they wouldn't exile them! Leafpool and Graystripe weren't exiled!

[eltonn]

^Mapleshade attempted to murder multiple cats, including her mate I believe. And you can OBVIOUSLY see in Crookstar's Promise that she has evil in her being. No cat in Starclan would do what she did to him in that manner.

[storm coming.]

*pokes thread*

hi!

BUT I HEARD BRIGHTHEART OMG I LOVE HER <3 *SPOILER* i felt so sorry for her when bluestar renamed her lostface . . . but yet she still remained strong. you have to give it to her, she was a very brave warrior indeed. perhaps even one of the bravest. she went through so much. but yet she survived both physically and emotionally.

*SPOILER* i think mapleshade would of deserved the dark forest though, considering what she did to poor old crookejaw/star. killing off his loved ones? it's just messed up. especially since he was oblivious to the whole idea of the curse. so, i think she did deserve it, after what she did to crookedjaw/star.

[Coco Bunny]

Yeah, some of those Dark Forest cats don't really deserve to be in there. I honestly didn't know about Brightflower and the fact that she's in there because she was angry as she thought Yellowfang had killed those two kits is pretty silly. And the fact that didn't Brightflower find out it was Brokenstar instead?
Isn't Su Suann just a fan as well? That's what I read.

Edit: WAIT. Wait wait wait. Is the Warriors Wiki serious?
"She went to the Dark Forest due to being furious about her broken leg, and unable to accept her fate." What?! This is absolutely stupid! I thought cats went to the Dark Forest because they were evil, not because they broke a leg!

[catbookdo]

Yeah I don't think that Mapleshade deserved the dark forest at first either, but as time went on, yeah she probably did deserve it. She's obviously very comfortable there, and look at what she did to poor Crookedstar.

And yes, I believe Su Suann is a fan that posts for Vicky on her Facebook account. I'm not sure if she had anything to do with it but she's the one that posted the message.

[montmorency]

I agree that a TV show would be great.
Also it would be interesting to see how the cats would react if a twoleg picked up one of the cats who got hit and like took it to the vets or somethin

(spoilers) im pretty sure in one of the books, somethingstar found an injured twoleg kit?? i cant remember if it was thunderclan or skyclan, rip.. that's the only time i can think of that twolegs WERENT trying to kill the cats smh

Barley got some twolegs to take in his severely injured sister, Violet.

[Esther~]

Spoilers Below

The hatred of her kit's death is what got Brightflower in the darkforest, I checked it up. However, she knew Brokenstar killed her kits because he admitted it in Into The Wild when the elders helped to take back the camp.

[Tendo64]

(spoilers)

I think Mapleshade deserved the Dark Forest, but she wasn't evil at first. She was maddened by grief, and I think being in the Dark Forest corrupted her worse. It's quite sad.

Also, I have a feeling those two she-cats were put into the Dark Forest simply because of the lack of female villains. Even with their resentment, these cats did nothing wrong and aren't evil...