~Warrior Cats Fan Club V.5~

[lyraish]

Why so much hate for sparkpaw?
I love her <3 very ambitious
My least favorite cat has to be (at least right now) alderpaw the only medicine cats I liked were leafpool and before her

Assumed Murder?
Bramblestar is her father and would deny it and most likely blame a rouge or another clan

Spoilers!
Because of my dislike for StarClan, I want to see a situation where StarClan misjudges the event and Sparkpaw has no choice because of a clear sign, maybe have Alderpaw turn on her. With that kind of backup from Starclan it would be undeniable, and she would have to be exiled even if it was in the wrong. I would then want Bramblestar to escort her to Riverclan for safety and have her grow as the arch-rival of Thunderclan, then becoming a clan leader and launching an attack only to find that the object of her hate (Alderpaw) is no longer a part of Thunderclan and is living in Shadowclan. I then want them to ally Riverclan and Shadowclan and start a fight against Thunderclan and Windclan + Starclan for all the misprophecies and needless deaths Starclan has given them. But i don't know, just my idea of a story. (literally none of this is canon or likely to become so, sadly.)

I think the reason Sparkpaw is so hated is that she has no visible flaws. She isn't a very interesting character right now but with the right plot she could grow into one, like an inner conflict situation where she has to fight not to be too ambitious and try not to let her anger get the best of her.

My question is why do you dislike Alderpaw? He can be whiny but right now he has very good character development and seems to have some real potential.

I don't really like spark paw or alder paw... There's just something to it

Sparkpaw is the perfect happy-go-lucky and everyone's favorite


Alderpaw is the whiny, kinda selfish brat who is the least favorite and the problem child

I dislike both, but they both could use some good time and they will probably get more interesting.

[if found]

Good point

[Msbunne]

Even some of the now most popular cats were like that at first

And I don't like alderpaw because I love medicine cats usually rp them and reading about them

At the end of can
Chapter 4 he said it just looks like a bunch of dead plants
That offended me he isn't ment to be a med cat

[lyraish]

Even some of the now most popular cats were like that at first

And I don't like alderpaw because I love medicine cats usually rp them and reading about them

At the end of can
Chapter 4 he said it just looks like a bunch of dead plants
That offended me he isn't ment to be a med cat

he really isn't, the decision to make him a med. cat was wrong. Mousewhisker shouldn't have been his mentor either.

[if found]

If you want another rp, check iridescenthyena's signature, because we have two we're doing together ( that need more people)

[montmorency]

Even some of the now most popular cats were like that at first

And I don't like alderpaw because I love medicine cats usually rp them and reading about them

At the end of can
Chapter 4 he said it just looks like a bunch of dead plants
That offended me he isn't ment to be a med cat

He was meant to be a medicine cat, and it's discussed near the beginning of the book.
At first, I think all medicine cats think of the herbs as 'dead plants.' Most cats do, as that's just what they are. Dead plants.

[if found]

I remember that part

[Msbunne]

The book says he is ment too but I personally don't approve of this

What if his sister gets sick and he gives her foxglove seeds instead of poppy seeds?

[if found]

Do foxgloves even have seeds?

[montmorency]

The book says he is ment too but I personally don't approve of this

What if his sister gets sick and he gives her foxglove seeds instead of poppy seeds?

Foxglove seeds are brown, while poppy seeds are usually black or off-white. And I'm sure they smell different as well.
But why would medicine cats keep foxglove seeds in the first place? Foxgloves can easily kill a cat, and they'd use deathberries if absolutely needed.

@~undertaletrash~ Yep.