Let's Read: Warrior Cats Series

[elfish]

wetkit.

i just shuddered a little inside.

@helmet boy, i believe dead- was a rename, if memory serves me correctly. deadfoot was hopkit before he was renamed during his apprentice ceremony.

[Woogwoo Wren]

Oh, and hopkit is so much better. Hoppaw. Really, Erins, really?

[elfish]

I dunno, the image of a kit hopping around his mother shortly after he was born is quite amusing cx

But yes, Hopkit isn't any much better. Oh, Hunter.

[agathokakologic]

And do we ever need to mention poor Maggottail?
I mean, really? Wow, no wonder he ended up in Dark Forest. Whatever stuff he did would have been highly centered around his abusive mother o_o

[Woogwoo Wren]

Wow! Which book was he in? I bet he's in shadow clan!

[agathokakologic]

Wow! Which book was he in? I bet he's in shadow clan!

I think Fading Echoes, for like 1 page where he creepily stares at Ivypool (Ivypaw at that time, I believe)
But I mean, we know he's bad. Bad cats don't need bad names to make it even more obvious that they're bad!

[elfish]

I'm convinced Erin only picked maggot- because, well, it sounds very unappealing and has negative connotations. He should've been named fly- instead, if Erin intended to stay on the that route. -sigh-

Then again, all of the dark forest cats have names that basically scream "I'm evil!" Clawface, Hawkfrost, Brokenstar.

[Atheon]

Did the cats ever mention maggots, let alone know what they are? o_o (and I know Deadfoot was a rename)

[agathokakologic]

Can we please have a clever villain who isn't obvious? Like, a big plot twist?
The biggest plot twist we've had is that Firestar is the fourth cat one, and believe me, it was lame.

[SklarmaDakflam]

Like, "look! a cat named Tigerclaw! Oh, he's cruel and mean to his apprentice! He wants to be deputy, and the two new deputies that aren't him die! Oh, and his poor apprentice says he killed the first! There is NO WAY he's going to be the main antagonist... WHAT! OMG! He IS the main antagonist! Who could've guessed."

Do you wanna know something I don't understand? Shadowclan. "Oh, look! Thunderclan has exiled this cat for treason and murder. Let's take this cat, from another clan who has committed unspeakable crimes, and make him our leader! That's the best idea we've had in moons!" And then Starclan is like "OK, bros. We'll make this evil cat your leader. We'll give him nine lives." Like, he is a BACKSTABBING MURDERER! And you make him Shadowclan's leader and give him nine lives, because he was so good and productive with his ONE life! Seriously!