Let's Read: Warrior Cats Series

[~Saturn~]

Since it was just mentioned that Graystripe became an elder, let me comment about that area -_-

Did anyone else find it completely annoying that when he was giving his little retirement speech that he claimed Bluestar's kits as his own instead of Feathertail and Stormfur? I mean...wha- is it that difficult to remember which kits were Bluestar's and which were Graystripe's? He literally said, "I'll never forget Silverstream and Stonefur and I can't believe that my daughter Mistystar became the leader of RiverClan."

Spoiler there, maybe, whoops. Still though.

No. Just no. That one I cannot forgive, Erin. Bad Erin. Bad.

[elfish]

Since it was just mentioned that Graystripe became an elder, let me comment about that area -_-

Did anyone else find it completely annoying that when he was giving his little retirement speech that he claimed Bluestar's kits as his own instead of Feathertail and Stormfur? I mean...wha- is it that difficult to remember which kits were Bluestar's and which were Graystripe's? He literally said, "I'll never forget Silverstream and Stonefur and I can't believe that my daughter Mistystar became the leader of RiverClan."

Spoiler there, maybe, whoops. Still though.

No. Just no. That one I cannot forgive, Erin. Bad Erin. Bad.

Wait, what? This really happened?

Man, I knew Erin Hunter make horrible mistakes but this is just beyond ridiculous.

[roxyuniverse]

I had to read that over and over again because I did not understand how they could make that stupid of a mistake.

*facepalm*

Really Erin Hunter

Really?

[Atheon]

spoilers maybe? graystripe's love story was really weird and a bit confusing. like hey lets just fall in love with the cat I don't even know and who saved me. had kits, she died like boom. move on to someone who looks like my old mate. yay kits. (I swear millie sits in the dang nursery all day and moons over briarlight)

[The Lion Queen]

Since it was just mentioned that Graystripe became an elder, let me comment about that area -_-

Did anyone else find it completely annoying that when he was giving his little retirement speech that he claimed Bluestar's kits as his own instead of Feathertail and Stormfur? I mean...wha- is it that difficult to remember which kits were Bluestar's and which were Graystripe's? He literally said, "I'll never forget Silverstream and Stonefur and I can't believe that my daughter Mistystar became the leader of RiverClan."

Spoiler there, maybe, whoops. Still though.

No. Just no. That one I cannot forgive, Erin. Bad Erin. Bad.

I- Wha-

...

I literally do not know what to say to that.

You had one job, Erin.

[elfish]

spoilers maybe? graystripe's love story was really weird and a bit confusing. like hey lets just fall in love with the cat I don't even know and who saved me. had kits, she died like boom. move on to someone who looks like my old mate. yay kits. (I swear millie sits in the dang nursery all day and moons over briarlight)

Millie and Daisy. Those are the two cats who really annoy me, partially because they refused to take on a warrior name and their whole personality in general.

That aside, I do agree that I felt that Greystripe's forbidden romance felt...forced. It didn't feel natural; it kinda felt like Erin Hunter thought to themselves, "hey, let's write a forbidden romance!" It's safe to say that Silverstream was a fairly boring character to me and her death failed to move me at all.

[Arcaii]

oh man this is too great
Marking
We need you're type of people- ones who point out every mistake in "great" books

Howdy, Hollyleaf!

AS A SIDE NOTE: I'M GOING TO DISNEYLAND TOMORROW, SO ILL LIKELY BE EXTREMELY BUSY IF NOT COMPLETELY ABSENT FOR A FEW DAYS. VERY SORRY.

[sweet tooth]

Millie and Daisy. Those are the two cats who really annoy me, partially because they refused to take on a warrior name and their whole personality in general.

Ugh. Yes. I always mix them up because they never changed their names, so when I try to imagine one of them, I think "Oh the cat that has the kittypet name."
BUT THEY BOTH HAVE KITTYPET NAMES
"Alright the one with kits"
BOTH HAVE KITS
ughhhhh

[Wolvine]

[stares at the sky] mistystar and stonefur are older than greystripe why is this happening

[Atheon]

I can just imagine the Erin's making more warrior cats with kittypet names... then BOOM there's a crap ton of kittypet named cats in the Clans -.-
What would be worse is just kittypet Clans. I can imagine it now... KITTYPET TAKEOVERS. WELL DONE.