The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Mikan Tsumiki.]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=97110646&userid=982241&signature=gHhnJvEQvBPDj3eqsPKNLg

Can i get an opinion on this trade? and if it's not fair, do i have to add to my side or their side?

[nicole]

another trade!
opinions on demand and rarity wise ^^
XXX

The cat can swap for the 2014 store pet on its own because they’re both .5 MAs/1 Low advent. The VR dog on your side isn’t necessary. Both sides have nice demand so it’s up to you on which side you prefer but as for now, it’s unfair to you with the VR dog on your side so I would remove it and edit it to be just the 2014 store pet on your side to make it fair

[shuichi]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=97110646&userid=982241&signature=gHhnJvEQvBPDj3eqsPKNLg

Can i get an opinion on this trade? and if it's not fair, do i have to add to my side or their side?

store pet values relevant to this trade:

2019 = early '10 rare
2018 = late '09 rare
2017 = mid-'09 rare

according to the pet worth thread, this wouldn't be exactly even (1 '09 rare on their end, 1.5 on yours), but if you're willing to trade these two for the pet on their end it isn't too much of an overtrade to be concerned in my opinion. if you'd like, i would suggest maybe getting rid of the 2019 store pet and adding an older rare instead, possibly an '11 rare or a late '10 rare to even it out as a 2017 store is only worth slightly more than your 2018 one! just try to negotiate to see what you both would be happy with if you don't want to trade both for it ^^

[mimitina]

is that fair for joker dog?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=97110138&userid=994729&signature=YdlDzMZYvj2r9fNw48mwww

help her

[horsestigers]

is that fair for joker dog?
trades/viewtrade.php?id=97110138&userid=994729&signature=YdlDzMZYvj2r9fNw48mwww

help her

rare warriors get 2-3 '09 rares x

dog plushie is worth around 1 MA x

Hammer, nails, gold/red cloth, and wizard token are around 1 MA each x

Raven perch order is going for 2 MA x

Re-release joker is worth 1.5 but TD is worth 2 x

the items add up to around 8 MA, which is only around .75n. Not fair for a joker dog.
(please get a second opinion as im not exactly sure about my answer)

[CalicoWolf]

Are these Fair?
XXX or XXX
Thanks in advance!

[horsestigers]

Are these Fair?
XXX or XXX
Thanks in advance!

ur tess cat is 2.5-3n x

mountain zebra is 0.75n x

both the plains and grevy's zebras are 1n xx

first trade comes to around 2.75n, and is technically fair, although the demand of the zebras is not that great


ur smore is 1.5-2n x

squid trades for 0.75n with consistency x

second trade comes to around 2.25-2.75n, and is a little less than the first trade, although the smore has better demand than the zebras

[Rbpuppy]

Out of curiosity, what is their side valued at? I’m not familiar with the UR on their side either.

trades/viewtrade.php?id=97095377&userid=42960&signature=bGWuCxiwXXgK8xx0kxLlzg

Thanks!

[polly pocket]

should i take this offer on my clockwork bunny?
it’s very tempting but i know i’m going to want another clockwork bunny in the future for my collection...
please help! ty in advance:)

honestly, no.
they may be offering a little more than 1.5n in c$ + 0.25n pet-wise
but c$ is rather hard to trade back into high value pets

thank you!
second opinions please?

[Mikan Tsumiki.]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=97110646&userid=982241&signature=gHhnJvEQvBPDj3eqsPKNLg

Can i get an opinion on this trade? and if it's not fair, do i have to add to my side or their side?

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=97112454&userid=982241&signature=-HIgOodS55ZjSLwIkL0MA

and what about this one?