The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Rbpuppy]

How’s this trade? Am I better off with the July PPS or is the non-coon easier to trade off?

Is this fair? I'm still trying to understand rarities on trading

trades/viewtrade.php?id=84963615&userid=921030&signature=FK9dcMW2AT9lo7WFuhefXQ

Massive overpay on C$ side. 2014 stores are worth C$40-45. Demand is subjective.

I personally think the Non is always easier to trade, but definitely get a second opinion

[amarok.]

How’s this trade? Am I better off with the July PPS or is the non-coon easier to trade off?

they both fetch the same price but the july pps is actually worth somewhere in the ballpark of 2 nons if you follow the list, so if you're feeling brave and think the market value of the pet may go up in the future/genuinely like the july pps i'd take it. if you're as cynical as me, i'd keep the noncoon. it doesn't have any specific demand as far as i'm aware and often ends up just being used as trade filler but it is currently considerably easier to trade than the pps.

[lumoseverdeen]

Is this fair? Idk the demand well for the kitsunes and the dogs on the other side. Thanks!

Also just got this trade for my UR Bengal--was wonder what demand was like for both the Bengal and Joker! Thanks!

[.Elysian.]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=84963736&userid=876971&signature=KsDjO5VcTpBHZDP_BzUGnA

Is this fair for my GWJ?

[scarluth]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=84963736&userid=876971&signature=KsDjO5VcTpBHZDP_BzUGnA

Is this fair for my GWJ?

GWJ goes for a non consistently. Zebra is also worth a non but it usually only reaches a sorb.

[Bud.]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=84964040&userid=914797&signature=nVlFds7wNeGnUkKlhw0G0g

Is this fair to me?

[amarok.]

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=84963736&userid=876971&signature=KsDjO5VcTpBHZDP_BzUGnA

Is this fair for my GWJ?

GWJ goes for a non consistently. Zebra is also worth a non but it usually only reaches a sorb.

i've never seen the zebra go for a sorb. it's usually regarded as being worth 3 nons but due to poor demand it fetches one. if you look at this guide here, compiled from raw cs data, the plains zebra is in fact one of the rarest pets on the site.

https://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=84964040&userid=914797&signature=nVlFds7wNeGnUkKlhw0G0g

Is this fair to me?

no. their side is somewhere in the ballpark of a '11 rare or 0.25 '09 rares by 2:1 maths. it's unfair to you. c;

[jointedwishes]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=84964069&userid=961979&signature=p6Yl0aytZ5PRWKaiRhKMAA

Was this fair for me?

[scarluth]

How’s this trade? Am I better off with the July PPS or is the non-coon easier to trade off?

they both fetch the same price but the july pps is actually worth somewhere in the ballpark of 2 nons if you follow the list, so if you're feeling brave and think the market value of the pet may go up in the future/genuinely like the july pps i'd take it. if you're as cynical as me, i'd keep the noncoon. it doesn't have any specific demand as far as i'm aware and often ends up just being used as trade filler but it is currently considerably easier to trade than the pps.

How’s this trade? Am I better off with the July PPS or is the non-coon easier to trade off?

I personally think the Non is always easier to trade, but definitely get a second opinion

Ah, okay, thank you! <3

[Magpie•]

trades/viewtrade.php?id=84963831&userid=941534&signature=_FbGyBDOKsOm9UQctGWYsQ
trades/viewtrade.php?id=84963902&userid=941534&signature=3qHzEFdOb-gVrMVd-wmxQw
Which one is fair and better?


PLEASE HELP ASAP