The "Is this a fair trade?" Thread

[Seasonal]

We're 150 posts early from the time that a new thread should be made to prevent clogging, but the sooner the better, I suppose!

Unsure if a trade is fair? Auctioning a pet and want to know which offer is best? Ask here.

If you want to know what your pet is worth, please ask here.

New rule:
-If you don't know your rarities at all, please don't give your opinion. Or, if you aren't sure, please make sure you add something along the lines of "I'm not positive, so get a second opinion." It'll keep fights away from the thread.

Ask away :D

[lind17789]

how about this?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... SZweOBEX9Q

[Vell]

Nice job with the bad advice. it was OMG So rare until the Rerelease. Then more came out. So was the UR Butterfly Wolf andthe UR cat. Once more members join, it will be back up to OMG So Rare just like the UR Butterfly Wolf and UR Cat will be too. Give it a month or so. I love how you're so quick to call someone a scammer when you don't really know. As far as value goes, the UR Mint Horse is about equal to a Nontag or a Nonswirl.

Nice job.

Yeah the UR mint is probably the most common OMG so rares but it is still quite rare.Although when I had one I found it very hard to find good offers on it ^^

[asta,]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... 5zCwhfvvGg They sent this to me then I sent it back witth a hold on. So, need an answer quick

[Samurai!]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=5183989&userid=130183&signature=A5FjV7CLr-LG5zCwhfvvGg They sent this to me then I sent it back witth a hold on. So, need an answer quick

Unfair to dogs.

[MerryEaster]

UR cat for all 4 sorbets?

[~Lost Firefly~]

all 6 soxic dogs for pink/white valentine malk horse+pink Shima/Creamsicle bunny. what should be added to the bunny/horse side?

[CSF]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=5183989&userid=130183&signature=A5FjV7CLr-LG5zCwhfvvGg They sent this to me then I sent it back witth a hold on. So, need an answer quick

Unfair to dogs.

Agreed, unfair to them

[Seasonal]

how about this?
http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... SZweOBEX9Q

You'll need to add a lot more to your side, such as some VR September '08 pets. The Sorbet is form July '08.

[brian emo]

What should I add to this?
08 advent tinsel tess horse
for
UR, red or green butterbun/any VR bunny?