The "Is This a Fair Trade?" Thread

[steakems]

Which trade is better? Thanks!
1
2

[musicgurl333]

Hi, is it okay if I trade away my grinner for a Shima? (Since Grinners have bad demand)

If you're okay with it, then it's okay. But it would be super unfair to you. The demand of grinners isn't that bad, and even with the shima's good demand, a September list pet is way over pay.

[~ t r o u b l e ~]

Hi, is it okay if I trade away my grinner for a Shima? (Since Grinners have bad demand)

grinners don't really have bad demand, they just don't generally go for overpay. They can get fair trades pretty easily from my experience with them and are good fillers in trading up
Either way it's unfair to the grinner

[elder price]

Hi, is it okay if I trade away my grinner for a Shima? (Since Grinners have bad demand)

If you're okay with it, then it's okay. But it would be super unfair to you. The demand of grinners isn't that bad, and even with the shima's good demand, a September list pet is way over pay.

agreed, grinners having bad demand is more like a myth. it takes patience sometimes, but i've never had issues with trading them away fairly, and i've had them many times. it'd be unfair to the grinner even with the shima demand

[.always.]

Hi, is it okay if I trade away my grinner for a Shima? (Since Grinners have bad demand)

If you're okay with it, then it's okay. But it would be super unfair to you. The demand of grinners isn't that bad, and even with the shima's good demand, a September list pet is way over pay.

agreed, grinners having bad demand is more like a myth. it takes patience sometimes, but i've never had issues with trading them away fairly, and i've had them many times. it'd be unfair to the grinner even with the shima demand

~trouble~ grinners don't really have bad demand, they just don't generally go for overpay. They can get fair trades pretty easily from my experience with them and are good fillers in trading up
Either way it's unfair to the grinner

Thank you so much for the advice guys!

[emoji movie]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/v ... pKS4BIkIcA

Would this be fair

[steakems]

Which trade is better? Thanks!
1
2

[miyadera]

What should I add? And to which side?

[quirkcirc]

I'm holding an auction for my Good PPS pup and I got this bid. I was wondering how fair or is considering the worth and demand of both pets. Is it overpay?
Any and all advice would be highly appreciated. I would be humbled if you took your time and reviewed my trade. Thank you in advance and have a lovely night/day ^^

[.always.]

Stuck between 2, 9, 10, 11
Help! Are any of them fair?
viewtopic.php?f=40&t=2572537