The "Is this a fair trade?" thread

[pɹɐdoǝן♥ʍous]

Is this fair?



Thanks in advance =)

[ZenonZogratis]

Are either of these fair?

http://i41.tinypic.com/2gtotfq.jpg

http://i41.tinypic.com/oj3ss8.jpg

Both are unfair to the other person.

No, they're not. The first one is unfair to you, since the dark-faced dog is from '08 and the grinner is from '09.

[JadeiteWren]

I need to know what the other person could add. What pet could make it fair? Another July? August?

Ur Cat for Pink Sorbet, Blue Sorbet, Non Tag, and Blue Toxic

And is a Rare Advent 2008 Lion fair for a Very Rare 2009 Store Halloween Bunny? If not would adding if not one or both 2009 Rare Valentine dogs do the trick?

[Minaethiel]

Is it fair to trade away a good shima PPS for 2 uncommons, 1 from this year and an 09 advent?

[Hyaenidae]

Is this fair?

[~Rachy~]

WAY unfair to you!

[Feather <3]

Would this original warrior cat:


Be a fair trade for any one of the following? ^^ Thank you!!

[huskynerd]

Is it fair to trade away a good shima PPS for 2 uncommons, 1 from this year and an 09 advent?

No, not at all. Those PPS will be rare soon I bet (honestly, I'm surprised they're not already).

And is a Rare Advent 2008 Lion fair for a Very Rare 2009 Store Halloween Bunny? If not would adding if not one or both 2009 Rare Valentine dogs do the trick?

They could add maybe one of the Valentines dogs. That bunny did cost 30 C$.

Is this fair?



Thanks in advance =)

Mm...maybe a teensy bit unfair to the bunny. But you wouldn't have to add much.

Would this original warrior cat:


Be a fair trade for any one of the following? ^^ Thank you!!

Yeah, sure. Either one. They're all the old ones right?

WAY unfair to you!

Chyeah, agreed.

[Feather <3]

Kk, thanks!! ^^
I just wasn't sure if one was more or less rare than another. :3

[JadeiteWren]

I need to know what the other person could add if it is not fair.
Ur Cat for Pink Sorbet, Blue Sorbet, Non Tag, and Blue Toxic