The "is this a fair trade?" Thread - info front page!

[justina valentine]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=59332023&userid=521044&signature=5_vvfdU4rUiB1VpL6g7SUQ
I really feel like this is fair, but I'm a slightly skeptical because I've had a couple of people try ripping me off for these little guys. Just wanted a second opinion. Thanks to any who answer!

Very Unfair to you! xoxo x

[ThunderCedar]

http://www.chickensmoothie.com/trades/viewtrade.php?id=59332023&userid=521044&signature=5_vvfdU4rUiB1VpL6g7SUQ
I really feel like this is fair, but I'm a slightly skeptical because I've had a couple of people try ripping me off for these little guys. Just wanted a second opinion. Thanks to any who answer!

very unfair to you, their side doesnt even add up to one of your pets.

[mellow.]

is this a fair trade..? Thanks in advance.
link here

[ThunderCedar]

How does this trade look? I'm not very familiar with store pet trades. Thank you in advance!

roughly fair technically, a '13 store pet is worth a mid-late 09 rare, but in my experience it's easy to get more than that for store pets.

is this a fair trade..? Thanks in advance.
link here

no.
i recognize that box, it's a palomino tess horse.
the demand of them is pretty low and trading them for even the lowest outcome of your rose dog litter is nearly impossible.

[ジョジョ]

How does this trade look? I'm not very familiar with store pet trades. Thank you in advance!

i believe your pet is worth a mid/late '09 rare ??
from what i can dig up from searching, a 2014 store pet is worth a late '09,
so because yours is 2013, and older store pets are worth more, it's safe to assume it's fair.
you might want a second opinion, though, if you're unsure about trading it away.

edit: looks like i'm the second opinion, haha!

[Seasonal]

New thread, please post here!
viewtopic.php?f=20&t=3299837